Takahashi M, Akagi M
Kanagawa Psychiatric Center Kinkou Hospital, Yokohama, Japan.
No To Shinkei. 1996 Aug;48(8):757-60.
Aggressive behaviors represent a major management problem in patients with dementia. Neuroleptics are commonly the selected psychotherapeutics for controlling severe aggression, especially the violent outbursts often seen in severely demented patients. But their efficacy for this problem is limited and their use is frequently complicated by side effects. Anticonvulsants such as carbamazepine have been advocated as alternatives. Although sodium valproate can also be a potential alternative, only a few cases were reported. A 69-year-old man was admitted for the control of agitation, wandering and violence. He had an 8-year history of amnesia. The mental status examination revealed severe global cognitive loss. Cranial computed tomography showed moderate brain atrophy and dilatation of bilateral temporal ventricles. A diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease was made. Initially he was treated with nuroleptics. Sulpride in doses up to 600 mg/day had no positive effect, but led to confusion and worsened aggressive behavior. Haloperidol in doses up to 4 mg/day or propericiazine 40 mg/day showed the same result as sulpiride. Carbamazepine had a moderate ameliorative effect on the agitation and violence, but the patient could not tolerate it because of muscle weakness. Then, we used sodium valproate 400mg/day and found this was effective. After one week muscle weakness appeared. Therefore, the dose was decreased to 200mg/day, achieving a blood level of 20.7 micrograms/ml. The patient's agitation was well controlled at that point and had no apparent side effects. Sodium valproate may be a useful agent in the treatment of aggression in patients with dementia.
攻击行为是痴呆患者管理中的一个主要问题。抗精神病药物通常是控制严重攻击行为所选用的心理治疗药物,尤其是在重度痴呆患者中常见的暴力发作。但其对该问题的疗效有限,且使用时常伴有副作用。诸如卡马西平之类的抗惊厥药物已被推荐作为替代药物。虽然丙戊酸钠也可能是一种潜在的替代药物,但仅有少数病例报告。一名69岁男性因控制激越、徘徊和暴力行为入院。他有8年失忆病史。精神状态检查显示存在严重的全面认知功能丧失。头颅计算机断层扫描显示中度脑萎缩和双侧颞叶脑室扩张。诊断为阿尔茨海默病。最初他接受抗精神病药物治疗。剂量高达600毫克/天的舒必利没有产生积极效果,反而导致意识模糊并使攻击行为恶化。剂量高达4毫克/天的氟哌啶醇或40毫克/天的丙嗪表现出与舒必利相同的结果。卡马西平对激越和暴力行为有一定改善作用,但患者因肌肉无力而无法耐受。然后,我们使用400毫克/天的丙戊酸钠,发现其有效。一周后出现肌肉无力。因此,剂量减至200毫克/天,血药浓度达到20.7微克/毫升。此时患者的激越得到良好控制,且无明显副作用。丙戊酸钠可能是治疗痴呆患者攻击行为的一种有用药物。