Cohen J, Carlet J
Department of Infectious Diseases and Bacteriology, Hammersmith Hospital, London, UK.
Crit Care Med. 1996 Sep;24(9):1431-40. doi: 10.1097/00003246-199609000-00002.
To determine the safety and efficacy of BAY x 1351, a murine monoclonal antibody to recombinant human tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha, in patients with sepsis.
An international, multicenter, prospective, placebo-controlled trial in patients with sepsis, stratified into shock/nonshock groups.
Forty acute clinical care facilities in 14 countries.
Of the 564 patients enrolled in the study, 553 patients received study drug or placebo.
Patients received 15 mg/kg or 3 mg/kg of BAY x 1351, or placebo, as a single intravenous infusion.
The patients were well matched for severity of illness and for risk factors known to influence the outcome of sepsis. There was no difference in 28-day mortality rates between groups (placebo group 66 [39.5%] of 167;3 mg/kg group 57 [31.5%] of 181; 15 mg/kg group 87 [42.4%] of 205). Approximately 9 months after this study had begun, an interim safety examination of NORASEPT, a North American Sepsis Trial using the same monoclonal antibody, indicated that there was no benefit to patients in the nonshock group and further enrollment of these nonshock septic patients into INTERSEPT was stopped. The analysis therefore focused on the 420 patients in shock. The primary efficacy variable was the 28-day, all-cause mortality rate: placebo group 57 (42.9%) of 133; 3-mg/kg group 51 (36.7%) of 139; and 15-mg/kg group 66 (44.6%) of 148 (not significant). Two secondary efficacy variables were identified prospectively: shock reversal and frequency of organ failures. Life-table analysis showed that in patients who survived 28 days, there was a more rapid reversal of shock in both treatment groups compared with placebo (15-mg/kg group vs. placebo group log-rank statistic p = .007, 3-mg/kg group vs. placebo group p = .01). Similarly, in patients surviving 28 days, there was a significant delay in the time to the onset of first organ failure (log rank 15 mg/kg vs. placebo p = .03, 3 mg/kg vs. placebo p = .07), and more patients in the placebo group developed at least one organ failure: 15-mg/kg group 33 (40.2%) of 82; 3-mg/kg group 39 (44.3%) of 88; and placebo group 45 (59.2%) of 76 (15 mg/kg vs. placebo p = .03, 3 mg/kg vs. placebo p = .06). No significant adverse events were associated with the monoclonal antibody treatment.
INTERSEPT provides additional clinical data implicating TNF-alpha as an integral mediator of septic shock. The study suggested a possible role for anti-TNF antibody as adjunctive therapy, but this possibility requires confirmation by another clinical trial.
确定重组人肿瘤坏死因子(TNF)-α鼠单克隆抗体BAY x 1351对脓毒症患者的安全性和疗效。
一项针对脓毒症患者的国际多中心前瞻性安慰剂对照试验,分为休克/非休克组。
14个国家的40个急性临床护理机构。
在参与研究的564例患者中,553例患者接受了研究药物或安慰剂。
患者接受15mg/kg或3mg/kg的BAY x 1351或安慰剂,单次静脉输注。
患者在疾病严重程度和已知影响脓毒症预后的危险因素方面匹配良好。各组间28天死亡率无差异(安慰剂组167例中有66例[39.5%];3mg/kg组181例中有57例[31.5%];15mg/kg组205例中有87例[42.4%])。本研究开始约9个月后,一项使用相同单克隆抗体的北美脓毒症试验NORASEPT的中期安全性检查表明,非休克组患者未获益处,因此停止将这些非休克脓毒症患者进一步纳入INTERSEPT研究。因此分析集中于420例休克患者。主要疗效变量为28天全因死亡率:安慰剂组133例中有57例(42.9%);3mg/kg组139例中有51例(36.7%);15mg/kg组148例中有66例(44.6%)(无显著差异)。前瞻性确定了两个次要疗效变量:休克逆转和器官衰竭频率。生存表分析显示,在存活28天的患者中,与安慰剂相比,两个治疗组休克逆转更快(15mg/kg组与安慰剂组对数秩检验统计量p = 0.007,3mg/kg组与安慰剂组p = 0.01)。同样,在存活28天的患者中,首次器官衰竭发生时间显著延迟(对数秩检验15mg/kg组与安慰剂组p = 0.03,3mg/kg组与安慰剂组p = 0.07),安慰剂组更多患者发生至少一次器官衰竭:15mg/kg组82例中有33例(40.2%);3mg/kg组88例中有39例(44.3%);安慰剂组76例中有45例(59.2%)(15mg/kg组与安慰剂组p = 0.03,3mg/kg组与安慰剂组p = 0.06)。单克隆抗体治疗未出现显著不良事件。
INTERSEPT研究提供了更多临床数据,表明TNF-α是脓毒症休克的重要介质。该研究提示抗TNF抗体作为辅助治疗可能具有一定作用,但这一可能性需要另一项临床试验予以证实。