Shea B T, Bailey R C
Department of Cell and Molecular Biology, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois 60611, USA.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 1996 Jul;100(3):311-40. doi: 10.1002/(SICI)1096-8644(199607)100:3<311::AID-AJPA2>3.0.CO;2-X.
We have analyzed the growth allometry of external body proportions in Efe pygmies from Zaire and combined these data with values from the literature for comparable dimensions in adult pygmies and nonpygmies. We sequentially tested the hypotheses that adult proportion differences between 1) male vs. female Efe, and 2) pygmies vs. nonpygmies result from ontogenetic scaling, or the differential extension of common patterns of growth allometry. Results indicate an almost complete concordance of allometric trajectories for male and female Efe. These preliminary analyses also strongly suggest that adult nonpygmy Africans generally differ from pygmies in their terminal size and correlated allometric consequences, rather than in more fundamental alterations of underlying patterns of growth. Biacromial diameter emerges as the measurement most likely to depart from this general pattern. These results provide further evidence that shifts in systemic growth hormones yielding differences in terminal overall body size may be accompanied by global and coordinated allometric transformations. Certain proportion differences previously interpreted by some as specific evidence of primitive retention in pygmies in fact reflect simple growth allometric correlates of the derive rapid size decrease in these groups. Selected divergent body proportions characterizing adult pygmies, previously interpreted by some as independent evidence of climatic adaptation, also reflect such allometric correlates of ontogenetic scaling. We critically assess arguments that the small overall body size of pygmies was specifically selected for reasons of thermoregulatory efficiency, and consider an alternative or complementary scenario, based on selection for small size in order to reduce caloric requirements.
我们分析了来自扎伊尔的埃菲俾格米人身体外部比例的生长异速关系,并将这些数据与文献中成年俾格米人和非俾格米人可比维度的值相结合。我们依次检验了以下假设:1)成年埃菲俾格米男性与女性之间,以及2)俾格米人与非俾格米人之间的比例差异是由个体发育缩放导致的,即生长异速关系的共同模式的差异扩展。结果表明,男性和女性埃菲俾格米人的异速生长轨迹几乎完全一致。这些初步分析还强烈表明,成年非洲非俾格米人在最终体型和相关的异速生长结果方面通常与俾格米人不同,而不是在潜在生长模式的更根本改变方面。肩峰间径成为最有可能偏离这一总体模式的测量指标。这些结果进一步证明,全身生长激素的变化导致最终总体体型的差异,可能伴随着整体和协调的异速生长转变。某些先前被一些人解释为俾格米人保留原始特征的特定证据的比例差异,实际上反映了这些群体中快速体型减小的简单生长异速相关因素。成年俾格米人特有的某些不同的身体比例,先前被一些人解释为气候适应的独立证据,也反映了个体发育缩放的这种异速相关因素。我们批判性地评估了关于俾格米人总体体型小是出于体温调节效率的原因而被特别选择的观点,并考虑了一种基于选择小体型以降低热量需求的替代或补充方案。