Amore M, Giordani L, Giorgetti G, Zazzeri N
Istituto di Psichiatria P. Ottonello, Università degli Studi, Bologna.
Minerva Psichiatr. 1996 Mar;37(1):29-33.
Delusional depression is characterised by the presence of symptoms such as hallucinations (typically auditory) and delusions either mood congruent and incongruent. Most commonly the content of delusions is consistent with the depressive themes: guilt, unworthlessness, poverty, death. Hallucinations, when present, are not elaborate and may involve voices that berate the patient for shortcomings or sins. Mood incongruent psychotic symptoms include persecutory delusions, delusions of thought insertion or thought broadcasting. Several pharmacological studies have demonstrated a differential response pattern in delusional depression and in nondelusional depression. Delusional depressives in fact, have a much lower response rate to tricyclic antidepressant treatment alone (20-25%) than nondelusional depressives (70-80%). The combination treatment with tricyclic and neuroleptic drugs leads to a dramatic improvement in the response rate in these patients (68-95%). The drugs most widely used are, for tricyclics, amitryptiline (150-215 mg/day) and desipramine (150-200 mg/day), and for neuroleptics, perphenazine (30-50 mg/day), but good results have also been reported with haloperidol (8-20 mg/day). The better results obtained with the tricyclic-neuroleptic association seem to be related to 3 factors: an increased tricyclic plasma level due to a competitive hynibition in the hepatic hydroxilation processes caused by neuroleptic agents: a dopaminergic blockade and an increased serotonergic and noradrenergic activity. Treatment with neuroleptics alone improves the symptomatology only in 19-50% of the patients. If the patient does not show a good response to the combination of tricyclics and neuroleptics, lithium augmentation (600-1200 mg/day) notably ameliorates the rates of clinical response (80-90% of cases). The treatment of delusional depressive patients with amoxapine leads to positive results in 70-80% of cases. Very good results have also been noted with bupropione (300-750 mg/day) after only a week of therapy. A complete symptomatological remission has been observed with 1-Dopa (1000 mg/day). The relatively low number of delusional depressive patients treated with SSRI to date does not allow to draw any consistent and definite conclusion on their real efficacy in this severe form of depression. For the continuation treatment it is recommended to continue the tricyclic-neuroleptic treatment for at least 6 months, at the lowest neuroleptic dosage which allows a long lasting clinical remission. Once the clinical remission is complete, the neuroleptic agent can be gradually tapered in some months, unless the patient had previous recurrence with the tricyclic agent alone. To the patients who show a symptomatological re-exacerbation during neuroleptic tapering, must be given again the combination treatment. In these cases it is important to assess more often and carefully the patient because of the increased risk of tardive diskinesia. Inconsistent results have been reported regarding the role of lithium in preventing relapses and recurrences: some authors suggest a prophylactic treatment with lithium and/o tricyclics in monotherapy to avoid the risks linked to a long-lasting neuroleptic treatment; others authors have documented a higher risk of relapse with lithium and/o tricyclics in monotherapy than with the tricyclic-neuroleptic combination treatment.
妄想性抑郁症的特征是存在幻觉(通常为幻听)和妄想等症状,这些症状与心境相符或不相符。最常见的妄想内容与抑郁主题一致:内疚、无价值感、贫穷、死亡。幻觉出现时并不复杂,可能涉及斥责患者缺点或罪过的声音。与心境不相符的精神病性症状包括被害妄想、思维插入或思维播散妄想。多项药理学研究表明,妄想性抑郁症和非妄想性抑郁症的反应模式存在差异。事实上,单纯使用三环类抗抑郁药治疗时,妄想性抑郁症患者的缓解率(20%-25%)远低于非妄想性抑郁症患者(70%-80%)。三环类药物与抗精神病药物联合治疗可使这些患者的缓解率显著提高(68%-95%)。最常用的三环类药物是阿米替林(150-215毫克/天)和地昔帕明(150-200毫克/天),抗精神病药物是奋乃静(30-50毫克/天),但使用氟哌啶醇(8-20毫克/天)也报告了良好的效果。三环类药物与抗精神病药物联合使用取得更好效果似乎与三个因素有关:抗精神病药物导致肝脏羟化过程中的竞争性抑制,使三环类药物血浆水平升高;多巴胺能阻滞以及血清素能和去甲肾上腺素能活性增加。单独使用抗精神病药物治疗仅能使19%-50%的患者症状改善。如果患者对三环类药物与抗精神病药物的联合治疗反应不佳,加用锂盐(600-1200毫克/天)可显著提高临床缓解率(80%-90%的病例)。使用阿莫沙平治疗妄想性抑郁症患者,70%-80%的病例可取得阳性结果。仅治疗一周后,使用安非他酮(300-750毫克/天)也观察到了非常好的效果。使用左旋多巴(1000毫克/天)可实现症状完全缓解。迄今为止,使用选择性5-羟色胺再摄取抑制剂(SSRI)治疗的妄想性抑郁症患者数量相对较少,因此无法就其在这种严重抑郁症中的实际疗效得出任何一致且明确的结论。对于维持治疗,建议继续使用三环类药物与抗精神病药物联合治疗至少6个月,使用能实现长期临床缓解的最低抗精神病药物剂量。一旦临床完全缓解,除非患者以前单独使用三环类药物时曾复发,否则可在数月内逐渐减少抗精神病药物剂量。对于在减少抗精神病药物剂量过程中症状再次加重的患者,必须再次给予联合治疗。在这些情况下,由于迟发性运动障碍风险增加,需要更频繁、仔细地评估患者。关于锂盐在预防复发方面的作用,报告结果并不一致:一些作者建议单独使用锂盐和/或三环类药物进行预防性治疗,以避免长期使用抗精神病药物带来的风险;另一些作者记录到,与三环类药物与抗精神病药物联合治疗相比,单独使用锂盐和/或三环类药物复发风险更高。