Tsai S P, Gilstrap E L, Cowles S R, Snyder P J, Ross C E
Corporate Medical Department, Shell Oil Company, Houston, TX 77252-2463, USA.
Am J Ind Med. 1996 Jan;29(1):75-87. doi: 10.1002/(SICI)1097-0274(199601)29:1<75::AID-AJIM10>3.0.CO;2-X.
A previous report presented the 1948-1983 mortality patterns of the Shell Deer Park Manufacturing Complex employees who were employed for at least 3 months from 1948 through 1972. The present study updates the earlier investigation by extending the vital status follow-up through 1989 and by expanding the cohort to include employees hired after 1972. As in the previous study, the overall mortality and cancer mortality for both refinery and chemical employees were quite favorable compared to residents in the local population. Among refinery workers, cancers for which a suspicion of work-relatedness was raised in the previous study, i.e. leukemia and cancers of the central nervous system and biliary passage/liver, no supportive evidence was found in this update. For both refinery and chemical plant employees, the mortality rate due to cancers of all lymphopoietic tissue increased with increasing duration of employment; this finding was also noted by the original study. This was also evident for lymphoreticulosarcoma in refinery employees and for leukemia in chemical plant employees. However, elevations of cancers of all lymphatic and hematopoietic tissue are primarily confined to employees who started work at the complex before 1946. By contrast, deaths from cancer of all lymphatic and hematopoietic tissue for employees hired after 1945 were 22% lower than the comparison population. Seven deaths with mesothelioma mentioned on the death certificates were identified, with 3.2 deaths expected, resulting in a statistically nonsignificant SMR of 219.
之前的一份报告呈现了1948年至1983年壳牌鹿园制造工厂员工的死亡率模式,这些员工在1948年至1972年期间至少工作了3个月。本研究通过将生命状态随访延长至1989年,并扩大队列以纳入1972年后雇佣的员工,对早期调查进行了更新。与之前的研究一样,与当地居民相比,炼油厂和化工厂员工的总体死亡率和癌症死亡率都相当低。在炼油厂工人中,之前的研究中怀疑与工作有关的癌症,即白血病、中枢神经系统癌症和胆道/肝癌,在本次更新中未发现支持证据。对于炼油厂和化工厂员工,所有淋巴造血组织癌症的死亡率随着就业时间的增加而上升;这一发现也在最初的研究中被提及。这在炼油厂员工的淋巴肉瘤和化工厂员工的白血病中也很明显。然而,所有淋巴和造血组织癌症的增加主要局限于1946年前开始在该工厂工作的员工。相比之下,1945年后雇佣的员工中,所有淋巴和造血组织癌症的死亡人数比对照人群低22%。在死亡证明上提到的7例间皮瘤死亡病例被识别出来,预期死亡人数为3.2例,标准化死亡比为219,在统计学上无显著意义。