Raabe G K, Collingwood K W, Wong O
Mobil Business Resources Corporation, Global Medical Services, New Hope, Pennsylvania 18938, USA.
Am J Ind Med. 1998 Jan;33(1):61-81. doi: 10.1002/(sici)1097-0274(199801)33:1<61::aid-ajim8>3.0.co;2-z.
The mortality experience of 7,119 workers who were employed at a Beaumont, Texas, refinery for at least 1 year between 1945 and 1987 was investigated. Mortality analyses based on standardized mortality ratios (SMRs) and 95% confidence intervals (95% CI) showed overall mortality was significantly lower than expected compared with the U.S. general population (SMR = 82, 95% CI = 79-86). Total cancer mortality was also lower than expected (SMR = 92, 95% CI = 84-100). Significant mortality deficits from several malignant and nonmalignant diseases were reported. A significant mortality increase in the broad category of lymphatic and hematopoietic cancers was found (SMR = 133, 95% CI = 103-170). This increase was attributed to a nonsignificant elevation in leukemia of all cell types combined (SMR = 139, 95% CI = 92-201) and a borderline significant increase in other lymphatic tissue cancer (SMR = 158, 95% CI = 101-235). The elevation in leukemia was confined to workers hired before 1950. Furthermore, the leukemia excess was shown to have peaked during the 1960s, with mortality no longer elevated post-1980. Analyses of cell type-specific leukemias showed a similar temporal pattern for acute myeloid leukemia (AML) which was not significantly elevated (SMR = 136, 95% CI = 59-268). Mortality from other leukemia cell types was similar to or lower than expected. Mortality from non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL) (SMR = 140, 95% CI = 88-211) and multiple myeloma (MM) (SMR = 121, 95% CI = 55-230) were increased, but neither was statistically significant nor likely to be related to refinery employment. No death from asbestosis was reported, and mortality from mesothelioma and pulmonary fibrosis was lower than expected. Lung cancer mortality for the overall cohort was similar to expected. For the overall cohort, analyses by duration of employment and time since first employment showed no evidence of any trends for increasing cause-specific mortality. Separate analyses of male workers employed in operator jobs showed mortality patterns that were more favorable than those of the total cohort. Maintenance craftworkers showed statistically significant elevations in mortality for prostate cancer (SMR = 145, 95% CI = 107-194), leukemia (SMR = 179, 95% CI = 111-273), and other lymphatic tissue cancer (SMR = 233, 95% CI = 138-368). Detailed analyses indicated that, among maintenance craftworkers, mortality was elevated for AML, NHL, and MM, but none was significant. Furthermore, no upward trend by duration of maintenance jobs was observed. A small increase of lung cancer was observed among maintenance craftworkers (SMR = 120, 95% CI = 99-145), which was borderline significant. No relationship between lung cancer and duration of maintenance employment was found. In contrast, a deficit of pulmonary fibrosis was reported among maintenance craftworkers (SMR = 62, 95% CI = 17-159). These findings are discussed in conjunction with results from other refinery studies, and the limitations of the study are discussed.
对1945年至1987年间在得克萨斯州博蒙特一家炼油厂工作至少1年的7119名工人的死亡情况进行了调查。基于标准化死亡比(SMR)和95%置信区间(95%CI)的死亡率分析表明,与美国普通人群相比,总体死亡率显著低于预期(SMR = 82,95%CI = 79 - 86)。总癌症死亡率也低于预期(SMR = 92,95%CI = 84 - 100)。报告了几种恶性和非恶性疾病的显著死亡不足情况。发现淋巴和造血系统癌症大类中有显著的死亡率增加(SMR = 133,95%CI = 103 - 170)。这种增加归因于所有细胞类型合并的白血病非显著升高(SMR = 139,95%CI = 92 - 201)以及其他淋巴组织癌症的临界显著增加(SMR = 158,95%CI = 101 - 235)。白血病的升高仅限于1950年前雇用的工人。此外,白血病过量在20世纪60年代达到峰值,1980年后死亡率不再升高。细胞类型特异性白血病分析显示急性髓系白血病(AML)有类似的时间模式,其未显著升高(SMR = 136,95%CI = 59 - 268)。其他白血病细胞类型的死亡率与预期相似或低于预期。非霍奇金淋巴瘤(NHL)(SMR = 140,95%CI = 88 - 211)和多发性骨髓瘤(MM)(SMR = 121,95%CI = 55 - 230)的死亡率有所增加,但均无统计学意义,也不太可能与炼油厂工作相关。未报告石棉沉着病死亡病例,间皮瘤和肺纤维化的死亡率低于预期。总体队列的肺癌死亡率与预期相似。对于总体队列,按就业时长和首次就业后的时间进行分析,未发现特定病因死亡率增加的任何趋势。对从事操作员工作的男性工人的单独分析显示,其死亡模式比总体队列更有利。维修技工的前列腺癌(SMR = 145,95%CI = 107 - 194)、白血病(SMR = 179,95%CI = 111 - 273)和其他淋巴组织癌症(SMR = 233,95%CI = 138 - 368)死亡率有统计学显著升高。详细分析表明,在维修技工中,AML、NHL和MM的死亡率升高,但均无显著性。此外,未观察到维修工作时长的上升趋势。在维修技工中观察到肺癌有小幅增加(SMR = 120,95%CI = 99 - 145),这接近显著水平。未发现肺癌与维修工作时长之间的关系。相比之下,报告称维修技工中肺纤维化不足(SMR = 62,95%CI = 17 - 159)。结合其他炼油厂研究结果对这些发现进行了讨论,并讨论了该研究的局限性。