Segal S P, Bola J R, Watson M A
Mental Health and Social Welfare Research Group, University of California, Berkeley 94720, USA.
Psychiatr Serv. 1996 Mar;47(3):282-6. doi: 10.1176/ps.47.3.282.
The study examined whether the prescription practices of clinicians in psychiatric emergency services differed for African-American patients. Prescription of antipsychotic medications and its relation to quality of care was a particular focus.
Data from 442 independently observed evaluations of patients in psychiatric emergency services were examined using multivariate analyses. The observations were made during a five-year period at four urban general hospitals in California.
Clinicians in the four emergency services, most of whom were Caucasian, prescribed more psychiatric medications to African Americans than to other patients and devoted significantly less time to their evaluations. African Americans received more oral doses and more injections of antipsychotic medications, and the mean 24-hour dosage of antipsychotics (1,321 milligrams) was significantly higher than for other patients (825 milligrams). The tendency to overmedicate African-American patients was lower when clinicians' efforts to engage the patients in treatment were rated higher.
The results highlight the importance of efforts to engage African Americans in the treatment process and the need for clinical skills and training to help bridge cultural distances.
本研究调查了精神科急诊服务中临床医生针对非裔美国患者的处方行为是否存在差异。抗精神病药物的处方及其与护理质量的关系是特别关注的焦点。
使用多变量分析检查了来自442例对精神科急诊服务患者的独立观察评估数据。这些观察是在加利福尼亚州四家城市综合医院的五年期间进行的。
四个急诊服务部门的临床医生(其中大多数是白人)给非裔美国人开的精神科药物比给其他患者开的更多,并且用于评估他们的时间明显更少。非裔美国人接受了更多的口服剂量和更多的抗精神病药物注射,抗精神病药物的平均24小时剂量(1321毫克)明显高于其他患者(825毫克)。当临床医生让患者参与治疗的努力得到更高评价时,给非裔美国患者过度用药的倾向较低。
结果强调了让非裔美国人参与治疗过程的努力的重要性,以及对临床技能和培训的需求,以帮助弥合文化差异。