Ma Y F, Li X J, Jee W S, McOsker J, Liang X G, Setterberg R, Chow S Y
Radiobiology Division, University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, USA.
Bone. 1995 Dec;17(6):549-54. doi: 10.1016/8756-3282(95)00387-8.
This article contains the histomorphometric evaluation of the effects of prostaglandin F2 alpha (PGF2 alpha) on cancellous bone from the lumbar vertebra and cortical bone from the tibial shaft of ovariectomized, osteopenic rats. These effects were then compared with those of prostaglandin E2 (PGE2). Three-month-old rats were either ovariectomized (ovx) or sham-ovx. Then, either PGF2 alpha or PGE2 in doses of 1 and 3 mg/kg/day was given subcutaneously for 21 days at 150 days post ovx. Histomorphometric analysis was performed separately on both the primary and secondary spongiosae of the fourth lumbar vertebral bodies (LVB) and on tibial shafts. The ovx rats exhibited osteopenia in both primary (-23% to -37%) and secondary (-20%) spongiosae of the LVB, but not in the tibial shafts at 150 and 171 days post ovx. In the LVB, PGE2 in doses of 1 or 3 mg/kg/day for 21 days restored trabecular bone volume to the levels of sham-ovx controls in the primary spongiosa. However, in the secondary spongiosa, the treatments only thickened the trabeculae. The effects of the PGF2 alpha treatment were similar to those of the PGE2 in both the primary and the secondary spongiosae. While both PGF2 alpha and PGE2 treatments stimulated bone formation in the LVB as indicated by the increases in labeled perimeter, tissue and bone area-based bone formation rates, PGE2 is about 10 times more potent than PGF2 alpha in these effects. The PGE2 treatment also elevated activation frequency in the LVB, while the PGF2 alpha treatment did not. The treatments differed in that PGE2 at these dose levels did not alter the eroded surface in the LVB while PGF2 alpha decreased it significantly. Thus, the increase of the ratio of labeled to eroded perimeter in the LVB in PGF2 alpha-treated animals was much more than that in PGE2-treated animals. In the tibial shafts, PGE2 in doses of 1 and 3 mg/kg/day produced new marrow trabeculae in 2 of 6 and 3 of 6 of the ovx rats. However, no new trabecula was found in PGF2 alpha-treated tibial shafts. Higher doses of PGE2 also increased periosteal labeled perimeter, MAR, and BFR/BS, while PGF2 alpha did not produce any significant change in these parameters. Both PGE2 and PGF2 alpha in doses of 1 and 3 mg/kg/day increased the labeled perimeter, MAR and BFR/BS and decreased the eroded perimeter in the endocortical surface. We concluded that both PGF2 alpha and PGE2 in doses of 1 and 3 mg/kg/day for 21 days exhibited anabolic bone effects. The effects were mostly confined to an increase in trabecular volume in the primary spongiosa of the LVB and in the endocortical surface of tibial shafts. The tissue level mechanism behind this appears to be that PGE2 and PGF2 alpha can both stimulate osteoblast recruitment and activity. Overall, we found PGE2 to be more potent than PGF2 alpha at the same dose level at the endocortical surface. Furthermore, new marrow trabecular bone formed only after PGE2 treatment. PGF2 alpha differed from PGE2 by significantly reducing the trabecular eroded surface in ovx rats.
本文包含对前列腺素F2α(PGF2α)对去卵巢骨质疏松大鼠腰椎松质骨和胫骨干皮质骨影响的组织形态计量学评估。然后将这些影响与前列腺素E2(PGE2)的影响进行比较。将3个月大的大鼠进行去卵巢(ovx)或假去卵巢手术。然后,在去卵巢后150天,以1和3mg/kg/天的剂量皮下注射PGF2α或PGE2,持续21天。对第四腰椎椎体(LVB)的初级和次级海绵体以及胫骨干分别进行组织形态计量学分析。去卵巢大鼠在去卵巢后150天和171天时,LVB的初级海绵体(-23%至-37%)和次级海绵体(-20%)均出现骨质减少,但胫骨干未出现。在LVB中,以1或3mg/kg/天的剂量给予PGE2 21天,可使初级海绵体中的小梁骨体积恢复到假去卵巢对照组的水平。然而,在次级海绵体中,这些处理仅使小梁增厚。PGF2α处理在初级和次级海绵体中的效果与PGE2相似。虽然PGF2α和PGE2处理均通过标记周长、基于组织和骨面积的骨形成率增加表明刺激了LVB中的骨形成,但PGE2在这些作用方面的效力约为PGF2α的10倍。PGE2处理还提高了LVB中的激活频率,而PGF2α处理则没有。这些处理的不同之处在于,在这些剂量水平下,PGE2不会改变LVB中的侵蚀表面,而PGF2α会使其显著降低。因此,PGF2α处理的动物中LVB中标记周长与侵蚀周长的比值增加幅度远大于PGE2处理的动物。在胫骨干中,以1和3mg/kg/天的剂量给予PGE2,在6只去卵巢大鼠中有2只和3只产生了新的骨髓小梁。然而,在PGF2α处理的胫骨干中未发现新的小梁。更高剂量的PGE2还增加了骨膜标记周长、MAR和BFR/BS,而PGF2α在这些参数上未产生任何显著变化。以1和3mg/kg/天的剂量给予PGE2和PGF2α均增加了标记周长、MAR和BFR/BS,并减少了内皮质表面的侵蚀周长。我们得出结论,以1和3mg/kg/天的剂量给予PGF2α和PGE2 21天均表现出合成代谢骨效应。这些效应主要局限于LVB初级海绵体和胫骨干内皮质表面的小梁体积增加。其背后的组织水平机制似乎是PGE2和PGF2α均可刺激成骨细胞募集和活性。总体而言,我们发现在相同剂量水平下,PGE2在内皮质表面比PGF2α更有效。此外,仅在PGE2处理后形成了新的骨髓小梁骨。PGF2α与PGE2的不同之处在于,它显著减少了去卵巢大鼠中的小梁侵蚀表面。