Hibbs R G, Weber J T, Corwin A, Allos B M, Abd el Rehim M S, Sharkawy S E, Sarn J E, McKee K T
U.S. Naval Medical Research Unit No. 3, Cairo, Egypt.
Clin Infect Dis. 1996 Aug;23(2):337-40. doi: 10.1093/clinids/23.2.337.
During an outbreak of type E foodborne botulism in Cairo in 1991, an investigational equine F(ab')2 "despeciated" heptavalent botulism immune globulin (dBIG) was provided to the Egyptian Ministry of Health by the U.S. Army. Of 54 patients known to have been treated with antitoxins, 4 received commercially available trivalent antitoxins, 45 received dBIG, and 5 received both commercial antitoxin and dBIG. Physicians recorded side effects in 10 (22%) of 45 patients who received dBIG; in nine cases, reactions were considered "mild," and in one case they were believed to be serum sickness. In contrast, possible serum sickness during hospitalization was recorded for two of four patients who were receiving commercial antitoxins. No complications of therapy were noted for any patient who was receiving both antitoxin types. In a separate study, 31 patients were contacted about their reactions to the antitoxin by telephone after discharge from the hospital. Seven (54%) of 13 patients attributed symptoms that they experienced while they were hospitalized to receipt of dBIG, while four (44%) of nine patients who indicated that they had received commercial antitoxins and one (20%) of five who received both commercial antitoxin and dBIG reported side effects before discharge. Data on the efficacy of the antitoxins were not obtained. In our experience, equine dBIG was at least as safe as commercially available antitoxins in treating type E foodborne botulism.
1991年开罗发生E型食源性肉毒中毒疫情期间,美国陆军向埃及卫生部提供了一种试验性马源F(ab')2“去特异性”七价肉毒中毒免疫球蛋白(dBIG)。在已知接受抗毒素治疗的54名患者中,4人接受了市售三价抗毒素,45人接受了dBIG,5人同时接受了市售抗毒素和dBIG。医生记录了45名接受dBIG治疗患者中的10人(22%)出现副作用;9例反应被认为“轻微”,1例被认为是血清病。相比之下,接受市售抗毒素治疗的4名患者中有2人在住院期间记录到可能的血清病。接受两种抗毒素治疗的患者均未出现治疗并发症。在另一项研究中,31名患者出院后通过电话联系询问他们对抗毒素的反应。13名接受dBIG治疗的患者中有7人(54%)将住院期间出现的症状归因于接受dBIG,而9名表示接受市售抗毒素治疗的患者中有4人(44%)以及5名同时接受市售抗毒素和dBIG治疗的患者中有1人(20%)报告在出院前出现了副作用。未获得抗毒素疗效的数据。根据我们的经验,在治疗E型食源性肉毒中毒方面,马源dBIG至少与市售抗毒素一样安全。