Saunderson T R, Langford I H
School of Environmental Sciences, University of East Anglia, Norwich, England.
Soc Sci Med. 1996 Aug;43(4):489-502. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(95)00427-0.
In order to achieve the suicide reduction targets proposed by the U.K. Government's The Health of the Nation document, it is necessary to determine its geographical distribution. This objective is approached using district level data for England and Wales, aggregated for 1989-92. Two techniques are used, and compared. The first is the traditional method of mapping Standardized Mortality Ratios (SMR), expressed as relative risks. The second technique employed is the relatively new method of empirical Bayes estimates (EBE). It is shown that this is a superior measure for an initial investigation of the distribution of suicide, as relative risks for this comparatively rare condition are highly dependent on the population size of the areas studied. Discernible trends of high risk are shown in high population density, urban areas for both sexes, and in economically depressed agricultural, rural areas for men. The effects of economic hardship, unemployment and social disintegration are suggested as contributing to this distribution in an initiatory or exacerbatory capacity, for those suffering from psychiatric vulnerability or existing mental illness. Suggestions are made for more detailed analyses of high risk areas.
为实现英国政府《国家健康》文件提出的降低自杀率目标,有必要确定自杀的地理分布情况。本研究利用1989 - 1992年英格兰和威尔士地区层面的数据汇总来实现这一目标。研究使用了两种技术并进行比较。第一种是绘制标准化死亡率(SMR)的传统方法,以相对风险表示。第二种技术是相对较新的经验贝叶斯估计(EBE)方法。结果表明,对于自杀分布的初步调查而言,这是一种更优的方法,因为这种相对罕见情况的相对风险高度依赖于所研究地区的人口规模。在人口密度高的城市地区,男女自杀风险均呈现出明显的高风险趋势;在经济萧条的农业农村地区,男性自杀风险较高。对于那些患有精神脆弱或现有精神疾病的人,经济困难、失业和社会解体被认为以引发或加剧的方式导致了这种分布情况。文中还针对高风险地区的更详细分析提出了建议。