Immunomodulation by thalidomide: systematic review of the literature and of unpublished observations.

Three decades of immunological investigations using thalidomide are reviewed. Both in vitro and in vivo investigations are in accordance with the clinical finding that thalidomide does not impede T-cell competence in the control of infection by mycobacteriae. The term immunosuppressant does not apply. The immunomodulatory effects of thalidomide are evident in a myriad of phenomenological changes, and a molecularly defined common denominator of these activities is not known at present. Critical assessment with the objective to account for the clinical activity of thalidomide in specific human diseases leads to a focus on effects of thalidomide on phagocytic leukocytes and endothelia. The former are responsive to thalidomide by modulation of cytokine synthesis in vitro and in vivo; this activity can be shown using monocyte-specific stimuli in peripheral blood mononuclear cells but also in other phagocytic cells like microglia. For technical reasons, endothelial cells have until now been tested primarily in vitro. However, there is solid evidence now from intravital microscopy that the induction of adhesivity in postcapillary venules by LPS is modulated by thalidomide. Altered surface antigen expression has been described on leukocytes obtained from humans and experimental animals treated with thalidomide, but convincing evidence is lacking for in vitro modulation of surface antigen expression on leukocytes (as opposed to the modulation of adhesion antigens on endothelial cells stimulated by LPS or exogenous TNF alpha in the presence of thalidomide). Therefore, in vivo redistribution is likely to account for some, if not all, changes in circulating leukocyte phenotypes. The immunopathological conditions most clearly responsive to thalidomide are vasculitic alterations of post-capillary venules either in the context of mycobacterial infection (in the case of erythema nodosum leprosum) or mucocutaneous aphths. In both instances (as in the majority of focal inflammatory lesions), leukocyte infiltration and cytokine responses, in particular TNF alpha, are present. Thalidomide acts clinically not only by palliation of existing lesions but also by prevention of recurrence. The mechanism operates in skin, mucosa and parts of the nervous system and is most readily explained by synergism of TNF alpha modulation and a separate point of action on leukocyte migration patterns.