Lundgren D L, Hahn F F, Griffith W C, Hubbs A F, Nikula K J, Newton G J, Cuddihy R G, Boecker B B
Lovelace Biomedical and Environmental Research Institute, Albaquerque, New Mexico 87185, USA.
Radiat Res. 1996 Nov;146(5):525-35.
This study was conducted to examine the carcinogenic effects of inhaled beta-particle-emitting radionuclides, particularly in lower dose regions in which there were substantial uncertainties associated with available information. A total of 2751 F344/N rats (1358 males and 1393 females) approximately 12 weeks of age at exposure were used. Of these, 1059 rats were exposed to aerosols of 144CeO2 to achieve mean desired initial lung burdens (ILBs) of 18 kBq (low level), 247 rats to achieve mean ILBs of 60 kBq (medium level) and 381 rats to achieve mean ILBs of 180 kBq (high level). Control rats (total of 1064) were exposed to aerosols of stable CeO2. Based on the 95% confidence intervals of the median survival times and the cumulative survival curves, there were no significant differences in the survival of groups of female and male exposed rats relative to controls. The mean lifetime beta-particle doses to the lungs of the rats in the four groups were: low level, 3.6 +/- 1.3 (+/-SD) Gy; medium level, 12 +/- 4.5 Gy; and high level, 37 +/- 5.9 Gy. The crude incidence of lung neoplasms increased linearly with increasing doses to the lungs (controls, 0.57%; low level, 2.0%; medium level, 6.1%; and high level, 19%). The estimated linear risk coefficients for lung neoplasms per unit of dose to the lung were not significantly different for the three dose levels studied. The risk coefficient at the lower level was 39 +/- 14 (+/-SE) excess lung neoplasms per 10(4) rat Gy; at the medium level the risk was 47 +/- 12; and at the higher level the risk was 50 +/- 9.0. The relationship of beta-particle dose to the lung and the crude incidence of lung neoplasms was described adequately by a linear function. We concluded that the risk of lung neoplasms in rats per unit of radiation dose did not increase with decreasing mean beta-particle dose to the lung over the range of 3.6 to 37 Gy. The weighted average of these three values was 47 +/- 6.4 (+/-SE) excess lung neoplasms per 10(4) rat Gy. To extend the risk coefficients for lung neoplasms to lower doses by experimentation will require much larger numbers of rats than used in this study.
本研究旨在检测吸入发射β粒子的放射性核素的致癌作用,尤其是在低剂量区域,该区域现有信息存在大量不确定性。总共使用了2751只F344/N大鼠(1358只雄性和1393只雌性),暴露时年龄约为12周。其中,1059只大鼠暴露于144CeO2气溶胶,以达到平均期望初始肺负荷(ILB)为18 kBq(低水平),247只大鼠达到平均ILB为60 kBq(中等水平),381只大鼠达到平均ILB为180 kBq(高水平)。对照大鼠(共1064只)暴露于稳定的CeO2气溶胶。根据中位生存时间的95%置信区间和累积生存曲线,暴露组的雌性和雄性大鼠的生存率与对照组相比无显著差异。四组大鼠肺部的平均终生β粒子剂量分别为:低水平,3.6±1.3(±标准差)Gy;中等水平,12±4.5 Gy;高水平,37±5.9 Gy。肺癌的粗发病率随肺部剂量增加呈线性增加(对照组,0.57%;低水平,2.0%;中等水平,6.1%;高水平,19%)。在所研究的三个剂量水平下,每单位肺部剂量的肺癌估计线性风险系数无显著差异。较低水平的风险系数为每104大鼠Gy有39±14(±标准误)例额外肺癌;中等水平的风险为47±12;较高水平的风险为50±9.0。β粒子肺部剂量与肺癌粗发病率的关系可用线性函数充分描述。我们得出结论,在3.6至37 Gy范围内,大鼠每单位辐射剂量的肺癌风险不会随着肺部平均β粒子剂量的降低而增加。这三个值的加权平均值为每104大鼠Gy有47±6.4(±标准误)例额外肺癌。要通过实验将肺癌风险系数扩展到更低剂量,所需大鼠数量将比本研究中使用的多得多。