Kankaria A, Lewis J H, Ginsberg G, Gallagher J, al-Kawas F H, Nguyen C C, Fleischer D E, Benjamin S B
Division of Gastroenterology, Georgetown University Medical Center, Washington, D.C., USA.
Gastrointest Endosc. 1996 Oct;44(4):416-21. doi: 10.1016/s0016-5107(96)70091-3.
Flumazenil is a competitive benzodiazepine antagonist that acts to reverse their sedative and hypnotic effects. It is indicated in the management of benzodiazepine overdose, but its role in the routine reversal of endoscopic conscious sedation has not been defined.
Patients undergoing diagnostic upper endoscopy who received sedation with either diazepam or midazolam alone were given flumazenil 0.2 mg incrementally immediately following the procedure until awake. They were then asked to repeat three psychomotor tests measuring cognitive and motor skills, with their baseline scores compared with postprocedure scores over a 3-hour period.
Full psychomotor function was restored to baseline values within 30 minutes after flumazenil in 79% of patients, with no differences in the reversal of psychomotor skill impairment observed between diazepam and midazolam sedation. There was no evidence of rebound sedation seen for up to 3 hours. No significant anterograde amnesia was evident in 78% of individuals.
These results demonstrate that flumazenil's effects on reversing psychomotor impairment are similar when midazolam or diazepam are used for conscious sedation. However, the potential usefulness of routine flumazenil reversal of conscious sedation will require further evaluation of specific psychomotor performance skills (such as driving a car) before we lift the admonition against leaving the endoscopic suite unattended, driving a vehicle, or operating complicated machinery for several hours.
氟马西尼是一种竞争性苯二氮䓬拮抗剂,可逆转其镇静和催眠作用。它用于苯二氮䓬过量的管理,但在常规逆转内镜清醒镇静中的作用尚未明确。
接受单独使用地西泮或咪达唑仑镇静的诊断性上消化道内镜检查患者,在检查后立即递增给予0.2毫克氟马西尼直至清醒。然后要求他们重复三项测量认知和运动技能的精神运动测试,并将其基线分数与3小时内的检查后分数进行比较。
79%的患者在使用氟马西尼后30分钟内精神运动功能恢复到基线值,地西泮和咪达唑仑镇静在精神运动技能损害逆转方面无差异。长达3小时未见反跳性镇静的证据。78%的个体无明显的顺行性遗忘。
这些结果表明,当使用咪达唑仑或地西泮进行清醒镇静时,氟马西尼在逆转精神运动损害方面的效果相似。然而,在我们解除禁止患者在数小时内无人陪伴离开内镜检查室、驾驶车辆或操作复杂机械的告诫之前,常规使用氟马西尼逆转清醒镇静的潜在效用需要对特定的精神运动表现技能(如驾驶汽车)进行进一步评估。