Ifrah N, Hunault M, Jais J P, Moreau P, Desablens B, Casassus P, Briere J, Le Maignan C, Andrieu J M
Service des Maladies du Sang, Chu Angers.
Leuk Lymphoma. 1996 Mar;21(1-2):79-84. doi: 10.3109/10428199609067583.
Hodgkin's disease (HD) confined below the diaphragm accounts for less than 5% of all patients with HD. Although the major characteristics of this presentation appear established, optimal modalities of treatment still remain difficult to define. From April 1972 to October 1988, 28 patients with newly diagnosed infra-diaphragmatic HD, clinical stages I or II have been treated with 3 successive prospective protocols combining initial chemotherapy and radiotherapy (40 gy). This series of patients accounted for 4,3% of patients with HD limited to clinical stages (CS) I and II. Overall survival and freedom from relapse at 15 years were 74,4% and 73% respectively, without significant differences between clinical stages I and II, presence or absence of B symptoms or histologic subtype. There is only a trend (p < 0,10) in favour of patients younger than 40 years. In all 7 clinically staged IA patients no relapses were seen and combined treatment does not appear to be better than inverted Y irradiation alone. On the other hand initial chemotherapy seems necessary in patients with CS II A and B since 15 of our 21 patients are alive in first CR whereas the crude rate of transdiaphragmatic nodal relapses may reach up to 53% following radiotherapy alone.
局限于横膈以下的霍奇金淋巴瘤(HD)患者占所有HD患者的比例不到5%。尽管这种临床表现的主要特征似乎已经明确,但最佳治疗方式仍难以确定。1972年4月至1988年10月,28例新诊断为横膈以下HD、临床分期为I期或II期的患者接受了3个连续的前瞻性方案治疗,这些方案结合了初始化疗和放疗(40 Gy)。该系列患者占局限于临床分期(CS)I期和II期HD患者的4.3%。15年时的总生存率和无复发生存率分别为74.4%和73%,临床分期I期和II期、有无B症状或组织学亚型之间无显著差异。仅40岁以下患者有一定趋势(p<0.10)。所有7例临床分期为IA期的患者均未复发,联合治疗似乎并不比单纯倒Y形照射更好。另一方面,对于CS II A期和B期患者,初始化疗似乎是必要的,因为我们的21例患者中有15例在首次完全缓解(CR)状态下存活,而单纯放疗后经横膈淋巴结复发的粗发生率可能高达53%。