Tsai S C, Kao C H, Wang S J
Department of Nuclear Medicine, Taichung Veterans General Hospital, Taiwan, Republic of China.
Kaohsiung J Med Sci. 1996 Oct;12(10):573-80.
For the evaluation of the effect of exercise on bone mineral density of adolescent athletes, twenty-nine Chinese male adolescent athletes, each of whom had regular training in his major sport which included baseball, swimming, judo and middle/long-distance running for one to six years and eight age-matched non-athletic controls were included in this study. Bone mineral density (BMD) was measured in all study subjects using dual photo absorptiometry at the second to fourth lumbar spines (L2-4) and the right femoral neck (FN). The results revealed the following: (1) the combined group of athletes had significantly greater BMD of L2-4 (1.08 +/- 0.09 g/cm2) than the control group (0.99 +/- 0.08 g/cm2) and a tendency for greater BMD of FN (1.15 +/- 0.13 g/cm2) than the control group (1.09 +/- 0.13 g/cm2); (2) judo majors had significantly greater BMD of L2-4 than baseball majors (P < 0.05), swimming majors (P < 0.01), track majors (P < 0.05) and controls (P < 0.005); (3) baseball majors had significantly greater BMD of L2-4 than controls (P < 0.05) and greater BMD of FN than swimming majors (P < 0.05), judo majors (P < 0.05), track majors (P < 0.005) and controls (P < 0.005); (4) body weight and body mass index (BMI) had good correlation with BMD of L2-4 and FN in control group, (5) in the combined group of athletes, weight and BMI were only strongly linked to BMD of FN, and not to BMD of L2-4. There was no good correlation between BMI and BMD of L2-4 and FN in any group of athletes. We concluded that (1) physical activity during adolescence may contribute significantly towards increasing BMD of athletes and (2) the training type may provide a specific stimulus for increasing BMD at specific localized sites experienced in training.
为评估运动对青少年运动员骨密度的影响,本研究纳入了29名中国男性青少年运动员,他们每人都在其主要运动项目(包括棒球、游泳、柔道和中长跑)中进行了1至6年的常规训练,同时纳入了8名年龄匹配的非运动员作为对照。使用双能X线吸收法在所有研究对象的第二至第四腰椎(L2 - 4)和右股骨颈(FN)测量骨密度(BMD)。结果显示如下:(1)运动员组合的L2 - 4骨密度(1.08±0.09g/cm²)显著高于对照组(0.99±0.08g/cm²),且股骨颈骨密度有高于对照组(1.09±0.13g/cm²)的趋势(1.15±0.13g/cm²);(2)柔道专业运动员的L2 - 4骨密度显著高于棒球专业运动员(P < 0.05)、游泳专业运动员(P < 0.01)、田径专业运动员(P < 0.05)和对照组(P < 0.005);(3)棒球专业运动员的L2 - 4骨密度显著高于对照组(P < 0.05),且股骨颈骨密度高于游泳专业运动员(P < 0.05)、柔道专业运动员(P < 0.05)、田径专业运动员(P < 0.005)和对照组(P < 0.005);(4)对照组中体重和体重指数(BMI)与L2 - 4和FN的骨密度有良好的相关性,(5)在运动员组合中,体重和BMI仅与股骨颈骨密度密切相关,与L2 - 4骨密度无关。在任何一组运动员中,BMI与L2 - 4和FN的骨密度均无良好相关性。我们得出结论:(1)青春期的体育活动可能对增加运动员的骨密度有显著贡献,(2)训练类型可能为训练中特定局部部位骨密度的增加提供特定刺激。