Pladevall M, Goff D C, Nichaman M Z, Chan F, Ramsey D, Ortíz C, Labarthe D R
University of Texas-Houston School of Public Health 77225, USA.
Int J Epidemiol. 1996 Oct;25(5):948-52. doi: 10.1093/ije/25.5.948.
The identification of myocardial infarction (MI) is typically based on finding events designated by a nosologist with the appropriate International Classification of Diseases (ICD) code, currently code 410. These codes are applied based on review of medical records or death certificates. However, other factors, including reimbursement considerations, may influence the coding process, especially for hospitalizations. Thus, the validity of using ICD code 410 to identify MI must be assessed.
The Corpus Christi Heart Project (CCHP) is a population-based surveillance programme for hospitalized MI. Patients were identified using concurrent ascertainment in coronary care units and retrospective review of medical records. Events were validated as definite or possible MI using data regarding chest pain, electrocardiographic changes and cardiac enzymes. The validity of using ICD code 410 to identify cases of MI was assessed by calculating the sensitivity, specificity, predictive values and efficiency of ICD code 410 versus the CCHP 'gold standard'.
Use of ICD code 410 identified 80.9% (401/496) of definite MI, but only 19.0% (243/1280) of possible MI. Only 12.3% (90/734) of discharges with an ICD 410 code received a 'no MI' designation based on the 'gold standard'. The efficiency of ICD code 410 for identifying MI was 92.0% for definite MI and 77.1% for definite and possible MI.
The use of ICD code 410 to identify hospitalized cases of MI results in a modestly biased overestimate of the number of definite MI hospitalizations; however, this approach warrants consideration due to the expense of validation procedures.
心肌梗死(MI)的识别通常基于找出疾病分类学家指定的具有适当国际疾病分类(ICD)编码的事件,目前为编码410。这些编码是根据病历审查或死亡证明来应用的。然而,包括报销考虑在内的其他因素可能会影响编码过程,尤其是对于住院病例。因此,必须评估使用ICD编码410来识别MI的有效性。
科珀斯克里斯蒂心脏项目(CCHP)是一项针对住院MI患者的基于人群的监测计划。通过冠心病监护病房的同步确诊和病历回顾来确定患者。使用关于胸痛、心电图变化和心肌酶的数据将事件确认为确诊或可能的MI。通过计算ICD编码410相对于CCHP“金标准”的敏感性、特异性、预测值和效率,评估使用ICD编码410来识别MI病例的有效性。
使用ICD编码410识别出80.9%(401/496)的确诊MI,但仅识别出19.0%(243/1280)的可能MI。根据“金标准”,只有12.3%(90/734)具有ICD 410编码的出院病例被判定为“无MI”。ICD编码410识别MI的效率,对于确诊MI为92.0%,对于确诊和可能的MI为77.1%。
使用ICD编码410来识别住院MI病例会导致对确诊MI住院病例数量的高估存在适度偏差;然而,由于验证程序费用高昂,这种方法仍值得考虑。