Legha S S, Ring S, Bedikian A, Plager C, Eton O, Buzaid A C, Papadopoulos N
Department of Melanoma/Sarcoma Medical Oncology, University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, USA.
Ann Oncol. 1996 Oct;7(8):827-35. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.annonc.a010762.
Metastatic melanoma is commonly treated with chemotherapy and/or biological agents used separately. In this study we have investigated the efficacy of combined chemotherapy using cisplatin, vinblastine, DTIC (CVD) and biological therapy using interleukin-2 (IL-2) and interferon-alpha (IFN-alpha) in patients with metastatic melanoma.
All patients had advanced, inoperable melanoma without prior treatment with chemotherapy or biotherapy, a performance status of ECOG 0-2 and no evidence of symptomatic brain metastases. The CVD regimen consisted of cisplatin 20 mg/m2/d x 4, vinblastine 1.6 mg/m2/d x 5 and DTIC 800 mg/m2 x 1, repeated at 21-day intervals. The biotherapy regimen included IL-2, 9 x 10(6) IU/ m2/d x 4 days and IFN-alpha 5 x 10(6) U/m2/d SC x 5 days. The CVD and biotherapy regimens were integrated initially, in an alternating manner at 6-week intervals and subsequently, in a sequential fashion where patients were randomized to receive either CVD immediately followed by biotherapy (CVD/Bio) or the reverse sequence (Bio/CVD). Patients were admitted to the hospital for IL-2 administration and for monitoring and treatment of IL-2 induced side effects. The phase II results of the integrated therapy (biochemotherapy) studies were retrospectively compared to our previously reported results with the CVD regimen used alone.
The alternating biochemotherapy program was used in 40 patients and the sequential biochemotherapy was used in 62 patients. The alternating regimen produced 2 CRs and 11 PRs for an overall response rate of 33% among 39 evaluable patients. The sequential biochemotherapy produced 14 CRs and 23 PRs for an overall response rate of 60% (95% CI, 47% to 72%). The sequence of CVD/Bio resulted in a higher response rate (11 CRs + 11 PRs (69%)) compared to the Bio/CVD sequence (3 CRs + 12 PRs (50%)). Although the duration of PRs was short (median, 8 months), the median duration of CRs was 3+years and 10 of 16 CRs are currently disease free for periods of 3+ to 6+ years. The median survival of patients receiving sequential biochemotherapy was 13 months compared to 9 months for the CVD treated group (P = 0.04). Treatment with biochemotherapy was associated with severe toxicity including intense myelosuppression, infections, IL-2 induced constitutional toxicity and hypotension. However, the IL-2 induced toxicities were generally manageable on a regular ward, except for 15% of the patients who required transfer to an intensive care unit for treatment of complications associated with the treatment.
The sequential combination of CVD with IL-2 + IFN-alpha appears to have produced an increase in the number of durable responses in patients with metastatic melanoma. The toxicity of this program, although severe, was manageable. The biochemotherapy regimen produced an apparent increase in the median survival compared to that observed with the CVD regimen. However, a prospective comparison of these two regimens will be required to confirm these observations.
转移性黑色素瘤通常采用单独使用的化疗和/或生物制剂进行治疗。在本研究中,我们调查了顺铂、长春碱、达卡巴嗪(CVD)联合化疗以及白细胞介素-2(IL-2)和干扰素-α(IFN-α)生物治疗对转移性黑色素瘤患者的疗效。
所有患者均患有晚期、无法手术切除的黑色素瘤,此前未接受过化疗或生物治疗,美国东部肿瘤协作组(ECOG)体能状态为0 - 2,且无有症状脑转移的证据。CVD方案包括顺铂20 mg/m²/d×4天、长春碱1.6 mg/m²/d×5天和达卡巴嗪800 mg/m²×1次,每21天重复一次。生物治疗方案包括IL-2,9×10⁶ IU/m²/d×4天和IFN-α 5×10⁶ U/m²/d皮下注射×5天。CVD和生物治疗方案最初以交替方式每6周进行一次,随后以序贯方式进行,患者被随机分配接受先CVD后生物治疗(CVD/生物治疗)或相反顺序(生物治疗/CVD)。患者因接受IL-2治疗以及监测和治疗IL-2引起的副作用而住院。将综合治疗(生物化疗)研究的II期结果与我们之前单独使用CVD方案报告的结果进行回顾性比较。
40例患者采用交替生物化疗方案,62例患者采用序贯生物化疗方案。交替方案在39例可评估患者中产生2例完全缓解(CR)和11例部分缓解(PR),总缓解率为33%。序贯生物化疗产生14例CR和23例PR,总缓解率为60%(95%置信区间,47%至72%)。与生物治疗/CVD顺序(3例CR + 12例PR(50%))相比,CVD/生物治疗顺序导致更高的缓解率(11例CR + 11例PR(69%))。尽管PR的持续时间较短(中位数为8个月),但CR的中位数持续时间为3年以上,16例CR中有10例目前无病生存3年以上至6年以上。接受序贯生物化疗患者的中位生存期为13个月,而CVD治疗组为9个月(P = 0.04)。生物化疗治疗与严重毒性相关,包括严重骨髓抑制、感染、IL-2引起的全身毒性和低血压。然而,IL-2引起的毒性在普通病房通常是可控的,除了15%的患者因治疗相关并发症需要转至重症监护病房治疗。
CVD与IL-2 + IFN-α的序贯联合似乎使转移性黑色素瘤患者的持久缓解数量增加。该方案的毒性虽然严重,但可控。与CVD方案相比,生物化疗方案使中位生存期明显延长。然而,需要对这两种方案进行前瞻性比较以证实这些观察结果。