Oyafuso M S, Longatto Filho A, Bortolan J, Rahal P, Bisi H, Lombardo V
Department of Pathology, Hospital A.C. Camargo, São Paulo, Brazil.
Pathologica. 1996 Apr;88(2):128-31.
The performance of cytological diagnosis in serous effusions was evaluated through a historical large series study which was carried out at Department of Surgical Pathology of Hospital A.C. Camargo. Files from the period of 1966 to 1990 were reviewed. Out of 4297 serous effusions samples (from 3379 patients), 2520 were pleural, 1763 ascitic and 14 pericardiac, with cytological report of malignancy in 917, 688 and 4 cases, respectively. Cytological diagnoses were confirmed true or false after correlation with the final diagnosis of the patients (clinical follow-up and/or histological evaluation). The results observed were 1982 false-negative, 21 false-positive, 1588 true-positive and 468 true-negative cases. Suspicious (161 or 3.75%) and inconclusive (77 or 1.79%) cases were not considered for statistical evaluation. Sensitivity, specificity, efficiency, as well as positive and negative predictive values were 44.5%, 95.7%, 50.1%, 98.7% and 20%, respectively. These values in pleural and ascitic effusions, separately showed similar performance, which was not observed in pericardiac samples due to small casistics. These data show low sensitivity and negative predictive values which contrast with the high specificity and positive predictive values that can be partially explained by the methodological limitations and invasive features of neoplasias.
通过一项在A.C.卡马戈医院外科病理科开展的历史性大样本研究,对浆液性积液的细胞学诊断性能进行了评估。回顾了1966年至1990年期间的档案。在4297份浆液性积液样本(来自3379名患者)中,2520份为胸腔积液,1763份为腹水,14份为心包积液,细胞学报告显示恶性肿瘤的分别有917例、688例和4例。将细胞学诊断结果与患者的最终诊断(临床随访和/或组织学评估)进行对比后,确定其真假。观察到的结果为1982例假阴性、21例假阳性、1588例真阳性和468例真阴性病例。可疑(161例或3.75%)和不确定(77例或1.79%)的病例未纳入统计评估。敏感性、特异性、效率以及阳性和阴性预测值分别为44.5%、95.7%、50.1%、98.7%和20%。胸腔积液和腹水的这些数值分别显示出相似的性能,由于心包积液样本数量较少,未观察到类似情况。这些数据显示出低敏感性和阴性预测值,这与高特异性和阳性预测值形成对比,这可以部分归因于方法学的局限性和肿瘤的侵袭性特征。