Wagner W
Department of Neurosurgery, Medical School, University of Mainz, Germany.
Brain. 1996 Oct;119 ( Pt 5):1507-21. doi: 10.1093/brain/119.5.1507.
Median nerve somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) were recorded in a total of 181 patients in coma and brain death. Special attention was paid to derivation of P14 (the positive potential occurring approximately 14 ms after median nerve stimulation) with different electrode montages, using midfrontal scalp (Fz), linked earlobe (A1/2), median nasopharyngeal (Pgz) and non-cephalic reference (NC) electrodes. The P14 amplitude (and, to a lesser extent, latency) were invariably lower in brain death than in coma. The potential was preserved in coma in all patients, but lost in brain death in 9.8% in Fz-NC and Pgz-NC recordings, in 23.2% in Fz-A1/2, and in 100% in Fz-Pgz. Thus, Fz-Pgz was the derivation yielding the most reliable results with respect to the distinction between coma and brain death and is therefore recommended as a confirmatory test, when other diseases interrupting the lemniscal pathway (isolated brainstem death, high cervical transverse cord lesion and focal bilateral lemniscal lesion) are excluded. Theoretical considerations lead to the hypothesis of different (rostral and caudal) segments of the P14 generator dipole being recorded by the different electrode montages. It is assumed that Fz-Pgz picks up the most rostral part of P14 (rP14) that is invariably lost in brain death and preserved in coma.
对总共181例昏迷和脑死亡患者记录了正中神经体感诱发电位(SEP)。特别关注使用额中头皮(Fz)、耳垂连接(A1/2)、鼻咽中部(Pgz)和非头部参考(NC)电极,通过不同电极组合推导P14(正中神经刺激后约14毫秒出现的正电位)。脑死亡患者的P14波幅(以及在较小程度上的潜伏期)始终低于昏迷患者。该电位在所有昏迷患者中均保留,但在脑死亡患者中,Fz-NC和Pgz-NC记录中有9.8%消失,Fz-A1/2记录中有23.2%消失,Fz-Pgz记录中有100%消失。因此,就区分昏迷和脑死亡而言,Fz-Pgz组合产生的结果最可靠,因此在排除其他中断薄束通路的疾病(孤立性脑干死亡、高位颈髓横断损伤和局灶性双侧薄束损伤)时,推荐将其作为一项确证性检查。理论上的考虑导致这样一种假设,即不同电极组合记录的是P14发生器偶极的不同(头端和尾端)节段。假定Fz-Pgz记录的是P14最头端的部分(rP14),这部分在脑死亡时始终消失而在昏迷时保留。