Waltking A E, Kiernan M, Bleffert G W
J Assoc Off Anal Chem. 1977 Jul;60(4):890-4.
A polarographic procedure for the determination of the tocopherols in vegetable oils was compared to a conventional gas-liquid chromatographic procedure. The polarographic method is 2-3 times more precise and more rapid, which is an important advantage for monitoring the nutritional value of processing conditions of vegetable oil-based products. Attempts to establish the validity of apparently slightly higher values for alpha- and gamma-tocopherols obtained by polarography has implicated the gas chromatography or derivative formation rather than the extensive prior manipulation of the sample for chromatography as the source of error. Essentially the same results were obtained for alpha-tocopherol, regardless of the technique used. However, more variable results which were product dependent were obtained for gamma- and delta-tocopherols when gas-liquid chromatography was used.
将一种用于测定植物油中生育酚的极谱法与传统的气液色谱法进行了比较。极谱法的精密度高2至3倍,速度也更快,这对于监测植物油基产品加工条件的营养价值而言是一个重要优势。极谱法测得的α-生育酚和γ-生育酚的值明显略高,为确定这些值的有效性所做的尝试表明,误差来源是气相色谱法或衍生物的形成,而非样品为进行色谱分析而进行的大量前期处理。无论使用何种技术,α-生育酚的测定结果基本相同。然而,使用气液色谱法时,γ-生育酚和δ-生育酚的测定结果变异性更大,且因产品而异。