Ross P, Heron J, Cunningham D
Cancer Research Campaign Section of Medicine, Royal Marsden Hospital, Sutton, Surrey, UK.
Eur J Cancer. 1996;32A Suppl 5:S13-7. doi: 10.1016/s0959-8049(96)00334-6.
Introduction of new agents on to hospital drug formularies requires the demonstration of efficacy, safety and cost advantages. An audit of the total monthly costs of 'Tomudex' (raltitrexed; administered every 3 weeks), a drug recently introduced for the treatment of advanced colorectal cancer, and three 5-fluorouracil-based regimens [5-day daily bolus (Mayo); continuous ambulatory pump; 48-h continuous infusion (De Gramont)] was undertaken. Patient-specific costs associated with fluids, concomitant medication and consumables were largely negligible, but chemotherapy was the main cost driver in the raltitrexed and De Gramont groups. Fixed inpatient costs were highest for the patients receiving the De Gramont regimen which required more impatient stays each month. Total costs (patient-specific plus fixed costs) were lowest in patients on the Mayo regimen (mean 954.03 Pounds; median 659.68 Pounds), followed by patients in the ambulatory pump (mean 1207.61 Pounds; median 749.19 Pounds), raltitrexed [mean 1256.93 Pounds; median 1087.14 Pounds (mean 1117.85 Pounds; median 959.34 Pounds when costs of protocol-driven visits were excluded)], and De Gramont groups (mean 2028.52 Pounds; median 1775.66 Pounds). The pattern of costs varied considerably between regimens, such that high drug costs, for example those associated with raltitrexed therapy, were partially offset by reductions in hospital visits and stays.
医院药品处方集引入新药需要证明其有效性、安全性和成本优势。我们对“拓美”(雷替曲塞;每3周给药一次)进行了每月总成本审计,该药是最近引入用于治疗晚期结直肠癌的药物,并与三种基于5-氟尿嘧啶的治疗方案[5日每日推注(梅奥方案);持续皮下泵注;48小时持续输注(德格雷蒙方案)]进行了比较。与液体、伴随用药和耗材相关的患者特定成本在很大程度上可以忽略不计,但化疗是雷替曲塞组和德格雷蒙组的主要成本驱动因素。接受德格雷蒙方案的患者的固定住院成本最高,该方案每月需要更多的住院天数。总成本(患者特定成本加固定成本)在接受梅奥方案的患者中最低(平均954.03英镑;中位数659.68英镑),其次是接受皮下泵注方案的患者(平均1207.61英镑;中位数749.19英镑)、雷替曲塞组[平均1256.93英镑;中位数1087.14英镑(排除方案驱动访视成本后平均1117.85英镑;中位数959.34英镑)]和德格雷蒙组(平均2028.52英镑;中位数1775.66英镑)。不同治疗方案之间的成本模式差异很大,例如与雷替曲塞治疗相关的高药物成本,部分被医院就诊次数和住院天数的减少所抵消。