Todorov C, Bazinet A
Département de psychiatrie, Université de Montréal, Québec.
Can J Psychiatry. 1996 Jun;41(5):291-8. doi: 10.1177/070674379604100506.
Study of the concept of perfectionism and its phenomenology, etiology, and treatment.
Review of the literature, phenomenological, and-clinical analyses.
The International Classification of Diseases introduced the notion of perfectionism into psychiatric discourse in 1977. In DSM-III, DSM-III-R, and DSM-IV, perfectionism is a diagnostic criterion of obsessive-compulsive disorder, but has never been defined in the psychiatric literature. We differentiate normal perfectionism and pathological perfectionism, which is of some psychiatric interest: normal perfectionism is manifested according to the aptness of the target and its sociocultural value, and is therefore selective and flexible, whereas pathological perfectionism is the compulsive pursuit of a performance level not required by the circumstances and idiosyncratic in nature. Its symptomatology may resemble that of obsessive-compulsive disorder, but is actually quite different: whereas obsessive-compulsive symptoms are absurd and the product of ego-dystonic compulsion, pathological perfectionism is experienced as a personal obligation, and retain an identifiable cultural objective.
The phenomenology of the normal and abnormal manifestations of perfectionism is well defined. While pathological perfectionism and obsessive-compulsive disorder are similar and may even share a common etiology, they should be considered 2 distinct clinical entities. The therapeutic approaches to pathological perfectionism remain empirical.
研究完美主义的概念及其现象学、病因学和治疗方法。
文献综述、现象学分析和临床分析。
1977年《国际疾病分类》将完美主义的概念引入精神科论述。在《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第三版、第三版修订本和第四版中,完美主义是强迫症的诊断标准,但在精神科文献中从未得到定义。我们区分正常完美主义和病理性完美主义,后者具有一定的精神科研究价值:正常完美主义根据目标的恰当性及其社会文化价值表现出来,因此具有选择性和灵活性,而病理性完美主义是对环境不需要的表现水平的强迫性追求,本质上是特质性的。其症状可能类似于强迫症,但实际上有很大不同:强迫症症状是荒谬的,是自我不协调强迫的产物,而病理性完美主义被体验为一种个人义务,并保留一个可识别的文化目标。
完美主义正常和异常表现的现象学已得到明确界定。虽然病理性完美主义和强迫症相似,甚至可能有共同的病因,但它们应被视为两种不同的临床实体。病理性完美主义的治疗方法仍基于经验。