Eigen M
Max-Planck-Institut für biophysikalische Chemie, Göttingen, Germany.
Biophys Chem. 1996 Dec 10;63(1):A1-18. doi: 10.1016/s0301-4622(96)02250-8.
A comparative kinetic analysis of mechanisms of prion diseases based on the "protein only" hypothesis is presented. The Prusiner mechanism of autocatalytic conversion of a host protein into a genetically identical, but conformationally different, prion state requires cooperativity in order to work, given realistic values of rate parameters. It then becomes phenomenologically indistinguishable from the Lansbury mechanism of plaque formation which is also a form of (passive) autocatalysis. Though the two kinds of mechanisms still may differ on the question which of the two monomeric protein conformations is the favoured equilibrium state they both require an aggregated state as the form that is eventually favored at equilibrium. While these considerations allow for a critical comparison of the mechanisms they do not yet tell us what the actual mechanism of infection is. Experiments rather indicate that the infectious unit in vivo may still differ from an in vitro form of aggregated prion proteins. Hence aggregation of the prionic form is most probably a necessary, but possibly not sufficient, prerequisite of infection. Be that as it may, the premise of a linkage between prion aggregation and infection offers a very sensitive method for diagnosing the disease at a very early stage, using fluorescence cross-correlation analysis. The possible analogies to Alzheimer's disease make such a prospect a "hot topic".
基于“仅蛋白质”假说,对朊病毒疾病机制进行了比较动力学分析。根据现实的速率参数值,普鲁辛纳提出的宿主蛋白自催化转化为基因相同但构象不同的朊病毒状态的机制需要协同作用才能起作用。从现象学角度看,它与兰斯伯里的斑块形成机制难以区分,而斑块形成机制也是一种(被动)自催化形式。尽管这两种机制在两种单体蛋白构象中哪种是有利的平衡状态这一问题上可能仍存在差异,但它们都需要聚集状态作为最终在平衡时占优势的形式。虽然这些考量有助于对机制进行批判性比较,但它们尚未告诉我们实际的感染机制是什么。实验反而表明,体内的感染单位可能仍与体外聚集的朊病毒蛋白形式不同。因此,朊病毒形式的聚集很可能是感染的必要但可能不充分的先决条件。不管怎样,朊病毒聚集与感染之间存在联系这一前提为使用荧光互相关分析在疾病极早期进行诊断提供了一种非常灵敏的方法。与阿尔茨海默病的可能类比使得这样一个前景成为一个“热门话题”。