Frumkin H, Solomon G
Department of Environmental and Occupational Health, Rollins School of Public Health, Emory University, Atlanta, GA 30322, USA.
Am J Ind Med. 1997 Jan;31(1):107-15. doi: 10.1002/(sici)1097-0274(199701)31:1<107::aid-ajim16>3.0.co;2-6.
Methylcyclopentadienyl manganese tricarbonyl (MMT) is an organic manganese compound recently approved for use in the United States as a gasoline additive. MMT use is expected to increase. This Commentary analyzes the impact of MMT use on population exposure to manganese, the health effects associated with manganese exposure, and the possibility that MMT use will lead to toxicity in the population. Although MMT use would result in only a small increment in most people's manganese exposure, certain populations will be disproportionately exposed. Although manganese is an essential nutrient at low levels, high-level manganese exposure leads to a characteristic severe nervous system toxicity. Pulmonary toxicity also occurs at high levels of exposure, and developmental toxicity to fetuses is an important concern based on more limited data. Selected subpopulations may be especially susceptible to the toxic effects of manganese. The critical question is whether the additional population exposure to manganese that would result from widespread MMT use would lead to toxic effects. Currently available evidence does not permit firm conclusions. Common sense and prudence therefore dictate that MMT not be used until further data are available and its safety is confirmed. Several measures are recommended to address the impending use of MMT in the U.S. gasoline supply.
甲基环戊二烯基三羰基锰(MMT)是一种有机锰化合物,最近在美国被批准用作汽油添加剂。预计MMT的使用将会增加。本评论分析了MMT的使用对人群锰暴露的影响、与锰暴露相关的健康影响,以及MMT的使用可能导致人群中毒的可能性。虽然MMT的使用只会使大多数人的锰暴露量有少量增加,但某些人群将受到不成比例的暴露。虽然锰在低水平时是一种必需营养素,但高水平的锰暴露会导致典型的严重神经系统毒性。在高暴露水平下也会发生肺部毒性,基于更有限的数据,对胎儿的发育毒性也是一个重要问题。特定亚人群可能对锰的毒性作用特别敏感。关键问题是广泛使用MMT导致的人群额外锰暴露是否会导致毒性作用。目前可得的证据不允许得出确凿结论。因此,基于常识和审慎原则,在获得更多数据并确认其安全性之前,不应使用MMT。建议采取若干措施来应对美国汽油供应中即将使用MMT的情况。