Kaufman D W, Kelly J P, Jurgelon J M, Anderson T, Issaragrisil S, Wiholm B E, Young N S, Leaverton P, Levy M, Shapiro S
Slone Epidemiology Unit, Boston University School of Medicine, MA 02146, USA.
Eur J Haematol Suppl. 1996;60:23-30. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0609.1996.tb01641.x.
Agranulocytosis and aplastic anaemia are rare but serious conditions known to be caused by numerous drugs. Most of what is known or suspected about the aetiology is based on case reports, with only a few formal epidemiological studies that provide quantitative estimates of risk. Updated results have been obtained from a combined analysis of data from 3 case-control studies that used similar methods: the International Agranulocytosis and Aplastic Anemia Study (IAAAS), conducted in Israel and Europe; a study conducted in the northeast US; and a study conducted in Thailand. Totals of 362 cases of agranulocytosis, 454 cases of aplastic anaemia and 6458 controls were included in the analyses. The IAAAS and Thai study were population-based, providing estimates of the incidence of the 2 dyscrasias. The overall annual incidence of agranulocytosis in the ambulatory population was 3.4/10(6) in the IAAAS and 0.8/10(6) in Thailand; by contrast the incidence of aplastic anaemia was 2.0/10(6) in the IAAAS and 4.1/10(6) in Thailand. A total of 21 compounds were significantly associated with an increased risk of agranulocytosis in the IAAAS and US studies. Excess risks ranged from 0.06 to 13 cases/10(6) users/wk; the most strongly associated drugs were procainamide, anti-thyroid drugs and sulphasalazine. An association with drugs that had previously been suspected was also seen in Thailand. The overall aetiologic fractions of agranulocytosis due to drug use were 62% in the IAAAS, 72% in the US and 70% in Thailand. Eleven drugs were significantly associated with an increased risk of aplastic anaemia, with excess risks ranging from 1.4 to 60 cases/10(6) users in a 5-month period. The most strongly associated drugs were penicillamine, gold and carbamazepine. Aetiologic fractions were 27% in the IAAAS, 17% in the US and 2% in Thailand, which paralleled the prevalence of use of associated drugs in the 3 populations. The present results confirm that agranulocytosis is largely a drug-induced disease, with similar proportions accounted for in 3 disparate geographic regions. By contrast, although many of the expected associations were observed for aplastic anaemia, most of the aetiology is not explained by drugs. For all associated drugs, the excess risks are sufficiently low that blood dyscrasias should not figure prominently in the balancing of risks and benefits.
粒细胞缺乏症和再生障碍性贫血虽罕见但严重,已知由多种药物引起。目前关于病因学的已知或疑似情况大多基于病例报告,仅有少数正式的流行病学研究提供风险的定量估计。通过对3项采用类似方法的病例对照研究数据进行综合分析,得出了更新结果:在以色列和欧洲开展的国际粒细胞缺乏症和再生障碍性贫血研究(IAAAS);在美国东北部开展的一项研究;以及在泰国开展的一项研究。分析共纳入362例粒细胞缺乏症病例、454例再生障碍性贫血病例和6458名对照。IAAAS研究和泰国的研究以人群为基础,提供了这两种血液系统疾病的发病率估计。IAAAS研究中门诊人群粒细胞缺乏症的总体年发病率为3.4/10⁶,泰国为0.8/10⁶;相比之下,IAAAS研究中再生障碍性贫血的发病率为2.0/10⁶,泰国为4.1/10⁶。在IAAAS研究和美国的研究中,共有21种化合物与粒细胞缺乏症风险增加显著相关。超额风险范围为0.06至13例/10⁶使用者/周;关联最强的药物是普鲁卡因胺、抗甲状腺药物和柳氮磺胺吡啶。在泰国也发现了与先前疑似药物的关联。IAAAS研究中因药物使用导致粒细胞缺乏症的总体病因分数为62%,美国为72%,泰国为70%。11种药物与再生障碍性贫血风险增加显著相关,5个月内超额风险范围为1.4至60例/10⁶使用者。关联最强的药物是青霉胺、金制剂和卡马西平。病因分数在IAAAS研究中为27%,美国为17%,泰国为2%,这与这3个人群中相关药物的使用流行情况相符。目前的结果证实,粒细胞缺乏症在很大程度上是一种药物诱导的疾病,在3个不同地理区域所占比例相似。相比之下,虽然再生障碍性贫血观察到了许多预期的关联,但大多数病因并非由药物引起。对于所有相关药物,超额风险足够低,因此血液系统疾病在风险和获益的权衡中不应占突出地位。