Solomon D A, Keitner G I, Ryan C E, Miller I W
Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior, Brown University, Providence, RI, USA.
Psychopharmacol Bull. 1996;32(4):579-87.
There are currently three mood stabilizers available for the maintenance treatment of patients with bipolar I disorder: lithium, valproate, and carbamazepine. Unfortunately, monotherapy with each of these conventional agents often fails. To improve outcome, clinicians utilize polypharmacy. Although the efficacy of this practice is largely unknown, because of the lack of controlled studies, data from the United States and Europe indicate polypharmacy is the rule rather than the exception. The few controlled trials that have been conducted indicate that (1) the specific combination of lithium plus imipramine provides no advantage over lithium monotherapy (notwithstanding the inadequacy of lithium monotherapy); (2) the specific combination of lithium and the depot neuroleptic flupenthixol provides no advantage over lithium monotherapy; and (3) the combination of lithium plus carbamazepine may be as effective as lithium plus haloperidol for acute and continuation treatment. Most of the literature on polypharmacy consists of case reports, retrospective chart reviews, and open-label prospective studies, and describes the use of numerous combinations of medications, including lithium plus valproate, lithium plus carbamazepine, and valproate plus carbamazepine. Preliminary findings suggest these combinations may be effective, and that clozapine and high-dose levothyroxine may each be useful as well when combined with other drugs. Further research is necessary to formally evaluate whether these drug combinations are more effective than monotherapy. Until such studies are completed, certain general principles regarding side effects, pharmacodynamics, and pharmacokinetics should be kept in mind when prescribing two or more medications concurrently.
目前有三种心境稳定剂可用于双相I型障碍患者的维持治疗:锂盐、丙戊酸盐和卡马西平。遗憾的是,使用这些传统药物进行单药治疗往往会失败。为了改善治疗效果,临床医生采用联合用药。尽管由于缺乏对照研究,这种做法的疗效很大程度上未知,但来自美国和欧洲的数据表明联合用药是常规而非例外情况。已进行的少数对照试验表明:(1)锂盐加丙咪嗪的特定组合并不比锂盐单药治疗更具优势(尽管锂盐单药治疗效果不佳);(2)锂盐与长效抗精神病药物氟奋乃静的特定组合并不比锂盐单药治疗更具优势;(3)锂盐加卡马西平的组合在急性和维持治疗中可能与锂盐加氟哌啶醇一样有效。大多数关于联合用药的文献包括病例报告、回顾性病历审查和开放标签前瞻性研究,描述了多种药物组合的使用情况,包括锂盐加丙戊酸盐、锂盐加卡马西平以及丙戊酸盐加卡马西平。初步研究结果表明这些组合可能有效,并且氯氮平和高剂量左甲状腺素与其他药物联合使用时可能也有用。需要进一步研究来正式评估这些药物组合是否比单药治疗更有效。在完成此类研究之前,同时开具两种或更多药物时应牢记关于副作用、药效学和药代动力学的某些一般原则。