Nagumo K, Hirayama K
Department of Neurology, School of Medicine, Chiba University.
Rinsho Shinkeigaku. 1996 Oct;36(10):1129-35.
Our previous study showed that the alternating knee tilt test in supine position is a useful method to assess the trunk rigidity. We investigated the progression of axial (neck and trunk) rigidity in Parkinson's disease (PD), striatonigral degeneration (SND), and progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) by using this method. We assessed rigidity on a scale of 0 (absent) to 3 (severe) on five parts of the body: neck, trunk, wrist, elbow and knee in 57 patients with PD, 13 patients with SND and 18 patients with PSP. In PD patients, the degree of neck and trunk rigidity correlated well with the duration of disease and the staging scale. There was neck rigidity in 27% of PD patients with unilateral involvement of the limbs, but the trunk tonus was normal in them. There was rigidity in the neck and trunk of all PD patients with bilateral involvement of the limbs. When the limb rigidity was predominant on one side, the trunk rigidity was predominant on the opposite side. In SND patients, the degree of neck and trunk rigidity roughly correlated with the duration of disease and the staging scale. In SND patients with unilateral involvement of the limbs, tonus of the neck and trunk was normal. In SND patients with bilateral involvement of limbs, there was rigidity in both the neck and the trunk. In PSP patients, the degree of neck rigidity correlated well with the duration of disease and the staging scale, but the degree of rigidity in the trunk and limb remained relatively mild even at the advanced stage. Accordingly, in PSP patients there was a dissociation of the degree of neck rigidity from that of trunk and limb rigidity. In conclusion, the assessment of axial (neck and trunk) rigidity may be useful for the clinical diagnosis of parkinsonism and the staging scale scoring.
我们之前的研究表明,仰卧位交替膝倾斜试验是评估躯干僵硬程度的一种有效方法。我们使用该方法研究了帕金森病(PD)、纹状体黑质变性(SND)和进行性核上性麻痹(PSP)患者轴向(颈部和躯干)僵硬程度的进展情况。我们对57例PD患者、13例SND患者和18例PSP患者身体的五个部位(颈部、躯干、腕部、肘部和膝部)的僵硬程度进行了0(无)至3(严重)级评分。在PD患者中,颈部和躯干僵硬程度与病程和分期量表密切相关。27%单侧肢体受累的PD患者存在颈部僵硬,但他们的躯干肌张力正常。所有双侧肢体受累的PD患者颈部和躯干均存在僵硬。当一侧肢体僵硬为主时,对侧躯干僵硬为主。在SND患者中,颈部和躯干僵硬程度大致与病程和分期量表相关。单侧肢体受累的SND患者,颈部和躯干肌张力正常。双侧肢体受累的SND患者,颈部和躯干均存在僵硬。在PSP患者中,颈部僵硬程度与病程和分期量表密切相关,但即使在疾病晚期,躯干和肢体的僵硬程度仍相对较轻。因此,在PSP患者中,颈部僵硬程度与躯干和肢体僵硬程度存在分离现象。总之,评估轴向(颈部和躯干)僵硬程度可能有助于帕金森综合征的临床诊断和分期量表评分。