Finch M D, John T G, Garden O J, Allan P L, Paterson-Brown S
University Department of Surgery, Royal Infirmary, Edinburgh, U.K.
Surgery. 1997 Jan;121(1):10-7. doi: 10.1016/s0039-6060(97)90176-8.
TNM staging of gastroesophageal cancer is improved by the use of laparoscopy for the detection of occult metastases and endoscopic ultrasonography for T and possibly N staging. Laparoscopic ultrasonography may combine the strengths of both of these techniques. The purpose of this study was to compare TNM staging by means of laparoscopic ultrasonography (Lap US), laparoscopy, and conventional computed tomography (CT).
TNM stage was determined by using Lap US, laparoscopy, and CT scanning in 26 surgical candidates with gastric or esophageal cancer in a blinded fashion. CT scans were also reviewed separately by an expert radiologist. Validation of findings was by means of final pathologic examination.
Resectability for potential cure was determined by means of Lap US with a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 91% versus 100% and 73% for laparoscopy and 75% and 60% for CT, respectively. Overall TNM staging was 82% accurate for Lap US versus 67% for laparoscopy and 47% for CT (chi-squared, 8.64, p < 0.005, and 10.4, p < 0.005, respectively). Accuracies for Lap US versus laparoscopy versus CT for N stage were 92% versus 84% versus 70%, respectively, for T stage were 92% versus 42% versus 60%, respectively, and for M stage were 89% versus 44% versus 62%, respectively.
T and N staging by Lap US were comparable to published results for endoscopic ultrasonography, and overall TNM staging was better. Lap US may provide the optimal preoperative staging for gastric cancer and has the potential to complement endoscopic ultrasonography in staging esophageal cancer.
通过腹腔镜检查来检测隐匿性转移以及通过内镜超声检查进行T分期(可能还有N分期),可改善胃食管癌的TNM分期。腹腔镜超声检查可能结合了这两种技术的优势。本研究的目的是比较腹腔镜超声检查(Lap US)、腹腔镜检查和传统计算机断层扫描(CT)在TNM分期中的应用。
对26例胃癌或食管癌手术候选患者采用Lap US、腹腔镜检查和CT扫描以盲法确定TNM分期。一名放射科专家也单独对CT扫描结果进行了评估。通过最终病理检查对结果进行验证。
Lap US判断潜在可治愈性切除的敏感性为100%,特异性为91%,而腹腔镜检查分别为100%和73%,CT分别为75%和60%。Lap US总体TNM分期准确率为82%,腹腔镜检查为67%,CT为47%(卡方检验,分别为8.64,p<0.005和10.4,p<0.005)。Lap US、腹腔镜检查和CT在N分期的准确率分别为92%、84%和70%,在T分期分别为92%、42%和60%,在M分期分别为89%、44%和6