Lando H A, Pirie P L, Roski J, McGovern P G, Schmid L A
Division of Epidemiology, School of Public Health, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis 55454-1015, USA.
Am J Public Health. 1996 Dec;86(12):1786-90. doi: 10.2105/ajph.86.12.1786.
The present study used telephone support both to sustain abstinence and to encourage renewed quit attempts in smokers who had completed an intensive smoking cessation clinic.
Subjects were hard-core smokers (n = 1083) who had attended a multisession cessation clinic. They were then assigned randomly to receive telephone support (intervention calls 3, 9, and 21 months after the targeted cessation clinic quit date) or no further intervention.
In the intervention condition, subjects who relapsed were significantly more likely to resume abstinence (that is, to recycle) than those in the comparison condition at follow-up (6 months: 17.8% vs 11.3%; 24 months: 25.7% vs 18.2%). Telephone support was not effective in preventing relapse, and overall differences in abstinence outcome were not significant.
The major hypothesis of the current study--that telephone support would enhance the resumption of abstinence--received partial support. However, there was no evidence either of an overall treatment effect or of an effect in preventing relapse. Telephone outreach may be more effective in the context of self-help or other less intensive interventions.
本研究采用电话支持来维持戒烟状态,并鼓励已完成强化戒烟门诊治疗的吸烟者再次尝试戒烟。
研究对象为参加过多阶段戒烟门诊的重度吸烟者(n = 1083)。然后将他们随机分为两组,一组接受电话支持(在目标戒烟门诊戒烟日期后的3个月、9个月和21个月进行干预电话随访),另一组不接受进一步干预。
在干预组中,复吸的受试者在随访时比对照组的受试者更有可能重新戒烟(即再次戒烟)(6个月时:17.8%对11.3%;24个月时:25.7%对18.2%)。电话支持在预防复吸方面无效,戒烟结果的总体差异不显著。
本研究的主要假设——电话支持将促进戒烟状态的恢复——得到了部分支持。然而,没有证据表明存在总体治疗效果或预防复吸的效果。在自助或其他强度较低的干预背景下,电话随访可能更有效。