Tuttle-Newhall J E, Rutledge R, Hultman C S, Fakhry S M
Department of Surgery, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill 27559-7210, USA.
J Trauma. 1997 Jan;42(1):90-9. doi: 10.1097/00005373-199701000-00016.
The low occurrence, nonspecific signs and symptoms, and high rate of associated morbidity and mortality of pulmonary embolus (PE) create major problems in the prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of PE. The purpose of this study was to analyze the frequency and outcome of PE in an entire state's trauma population using a large, population-based, hospital discharge data base. With the inclusion of an entire population, the reported incidence, high risk groups of patients, and specific risk factors regarding PE were assessed. A multivariate, logistic regression model was created from the data to determine predictive power of selected risk factors in patients at risk.
The data source was a statewide, hospital discharge data base that includes data on all hospitalized patients for all of the hospitals in North Carolina. Data were available from 1988 to 1993. Using primary discharge diagnosis and nine additional ICD-9 coded diagnoses from the discharge abstract, patients were selected by presence of diagnostic codes for traumatic injury (800-959.9) and PE (415.1). Statistical analysis was performed using univariate and multivariate analysis to determine significant risk factors and to create a candidate model for the prediction of risk in the study population.
Of 318,554 patients, 952 (0.30%) had a recorded diagnosis of PE. The mortality rate for patients with PE (26%) was 10 times higher than the mortality rate in patients without PE (2.6%). In evaluating specific risk factors, age was a significant predictor of the risk of PE: 0.05% for patients under age 55 and 0.7% in those 55 years and over. The rate of PE, 0.3%, was low for the entire study population, but was highest in patients with injuries of the extremities, 0.53%. Increasing Injury Severity Score and Abbreviated Injury Scale score for determined body systems were also found to correlate with an increasing risk of PE. Over the course of the study, the incidence of PE among patients discharged from non-trauma centers showed a significant decrease. There was also a decrease in the mortality in non-trauma centers for PE. This finding cannot be due to coding changes coincident with the advent of diagnosis related groups because it would be associated with more vigorous combing of charts for diagnoses? It may well be that the use of prophylactic measures in injured patients initially used at trauma centers was adopted by the physicians at non-trauma centers over this time with the resultant decline in PE and associated mortality. From the univariate linear regression models, a logistic regression model was created that confirmed age as the most significant risk factor, followed by Injury Severity Score and Abbreviated Injury Scale score for soft tissue, extremity, and chest. The calculated area under the receiver operator characteristic curve was 0.72.
Using a large, population-based data base, we were able to determine the reported incidence of PE among trauma patients and establish specific risk factors. The reported incidence of PE in this population is low, 0.30%. The mortality among those with PE, however, is significant at 26%. In this study, age, Injury Severity Score, and injury to specific body regions (soft tissue, extremity, chest) were associated with an increased risk of PE. The investigation of prophylaxis of PE and the general management of injured patients may be influenced by the overall low reported frequency of PE and the specific high risk populations described in this study. In light of the low incidence of PE in patients without specific risk factors, prophylactic interventions cannot be routinely recommended unless their benefits clearly outweigh their risks.
肺栓塞(PE)发生率低、体征和症状不具特异性,且相关发病率和死亡率高,这给PE的预防、诊断和治疗带来了重大问题。本研究的目的是利用一个基于人群的大型医院出院数据库,分析整个州创伤人群中PE的发生频率及转归。纳入整个人群后,评估了报告的发病率、PE高危患者群体及PE的特定危险因素。根据这些数据建立了一个多变量逻辑回归模型,以确定选定危险因素对高危患者的预测能力。
数据来源是一个全州范围的医院出院数据库,其中包含北卡罗来纳州所有医院所有住院患者的数据。数据可追溯至1988年至1993年。利用主要出院诊断和出院摘要中的另外9个国际疾病分类第九版(ICD - 9)编码诊断,通过存在创伤性损伤(800 - 959.9)和PE(415.1)的诊断编码来选择患者。采用单变量和多变量分析进行统计分析,以确定显著危险因素,并建立一个用于预测研究人群风险的候选模型。
在318,554例患者中,952例(0.30%)有PE的记录诊断。PE患者的死亡率(26%)比无PE患者的死亡率(2.6%)高10倍。在评估特定危险因素时,年龄是PE风险的显著预测因素:55岁以下患者为0.05%,55岁及以上患者为0.7%。整个研究人群的PE发生率为0.3%,较低,但在四肢受伤患者中最高,为0.53%。还发现损伤严重程度评分及特定身体系统的简明损伤量表评分增加与PE风险增加相关。在研究过程中,非创伤中心出院患者中PE的发生率显著下降。非创伤中心PE患者的死亡率也有所下降。这一发现并非由于与诊断相关分组出现同时发生的编码变化,因为这会与更积极地梳理病历以查找诊断相关?很可能是在此期间非创伤中心的医生采用了最初在创伤中心用于受伤患者的预防措施,从而导致PE及其相关死亡率下降。从单变量线性回归模型中,建立了一个逻辑回归模型,确认年龄是最显著的危险因素,其次是软组织、四肢和胸部的损伤严重程度评分及简明损伤量表评分。计算得出的受试者工作特征曲线下面积为0.72。
利用一个基于人群的大型数据库,我们能够确定创伤患者中报告的PE发病率,并确定特定危险因素。该人群中报告的PE发病率较低,为0.30%。然而,PE患者的死亡率高达26%,相当可观。在本研究中,年龄、损伤严重程度评分以及特定身体区域(软组织、四肢、胸部)的损伤与PE风险增加相关。本研究中报告的PE总体频率较低以及所描述的特定高危人群,可能会影响对PE预防及受伤患者总体管理的研究。鉴于无特定危险因素患者中PE的发生率较低,除非预防性干预的益处明显大于风险,否则不能常规推荐。