Wittmann D H, Schein M
Department of Surgery, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee 53226, USA.
Am J Surg. 1996 Dec;172(6A):26S-32S. doi: 10.1016/s0002-9610(96)00347-9.
Excessive duration of antibiotics for prophylaxis and treatment of surgical infection appears to be the principal reason for "inappropriate" administration in current surgical practice. The main factors to blame are the inability of the clinician to distinguish between contamination, infection, and inflammation. Failure to distinguish between contamination and infection is the reason that prophylaxis is unnecessarily carried through into the postoperative phase for prolonged periods. Failure to distinguish between infection and inflammation misguides surgeons to continue antibiotics for unnecessarily long treatment periods. The concept for shortening courses of antibiotic administration is supported by a forum of experts. The majority of experts also favored a trend away from the use of therapeutic courses of fixed duration, by tailoring the duration of administration to the intraoperative findings to shorten treatment courses. Specific recommendations are (1) contamination: single dose prophylaxis (gastroduodenal peptic perforations operated within 12 hours, traumatic enteric perforations operated within 12 hours, peritoneal contamination with bowel contents during elective or emergency procedures, early or phlegmonous appendicitis, or phlegmonous cholecystitis); (2) resectable infection: 24-hour postoperative antibiotics (appendectomy for gangrenous appendicitis, cholecystectomy for gangrenous cholecystitis, bowel resection for ischemic or strangulated "dead" bowel without frank perforation); (3) advanced infection: 48 hours to 5 days, based on operative findings and patient's condition (intra-abdominal infection from diverse sources); (4) severe infection with the source not easily controllable: longer administration periods may be necessary (e.g., infected pancreatic necrosis).
在当前外科手术实践中,预防和治疗手术感染时抗生素使用时间过长似乎是“不合理”用药的主要原因。主要原因在于临床医生无法区分污染、感染和炎症。无法区分污染和感染导致预防性用药不必要地延长至术后阶段。无法区分感染和炎症误导外科医生不必要地长时间持续使用抗生素。缩短抗生素使用疗程的理念得到了专家论坛的支持。大多数专家还赞成摒弃固定疗程的治疗方式,根据术中发现调整用药时间以缩短治疗疗程。具体建议如下:(1)污染:单次剂量预防用药(12小时内进行手术的胃十二指肠消化性穿孔、12小时内进行手术的外伤性肠穿孔、择期或急诊手术中肠内容物污染腹膜、早期或蜂窝织炎性阑尾炎或蜂窝织炎性胆囊炎);(2)可切除性感染:术后24小时使用抗生素(坏疽性阑尾炎行阑尾切除术、坏疽性胆囊炎行胆囊切除术、无明显穿孔的缺血性或绞窄性“坏死”肠管行肠切除术);(3)进展期感染:根据手术发现和患者情况使用48小时至5天(各种来源的腹腔内感染);(4)感染源不易控制的严重感染:可能需要更长的用药时间(如感染性胰腺坏死)。