Pilot study of intraoperative high dose rate brachytherapy for head and neck cancer.

PURPOSE

To develop a new technique, intraoperative high dose rate brachytherapy (IOHDR), to deliver localized radiation therapy intraoperatively to head and neck tumors at sites inaccessible to intraoperative electron beam radiotherapy (IOEBRT) in the skull base region.

METHODS

After maximal surgical resection, afterloading catheters spaced 1 cm apart embedded in custom surface applicators made of foam or silicone were placed on resected tumor beds. IOHDR was delivered in a shielded operating room using preplanned dosimetry with a nominal 10 Ci iridium-192 source in an HDR micro-Selectron afterloader. Twenty-nine patients (20 males, 9 females) ranging in age from 9 to 80 years (median = 61) were irradiated intraoperatively for advanced head and neck tumors at sites inaccessible to IOEBRT. Six patients who had previously received external beam radiation (EBRT) ranging from 50 to 75 Gy, were given 15 Gy of IOHDR only. Twenty-three patients who had no prior radiation received 7.5 to 12.5 Gy IOHDR, and 45 to 50 Gy EBRT was planned post-operatively; however, six of these patients did not complete the planned EBRT. Doses to normal tissues were reduced whenever possible by shielding with lead or by displacement with gauze or retractors. Treatment time ranged from 3.8 to 23 min (median = 6.5 min). Five patients received concurrent cis-platinum based chemotherapy.

RESULTS

Twenty-nine patients treated to 30 sites had local tumor control of 67% and crade survival of 72%, with the follow-up ranging from 3 to 33 months (median = 21 months). In the group of 17 previously unirradiated patients who had completed full treatment (IOHDR and EBRT) to 18 sites, the local tumor control was 89%, and all of these patients survived. Tumor control in the six previously unirradiated patients who did not complete EBRT was 50% with a crude survival of 50%. In the group of six previously irradiated patients treated by IOHDR only, the local tumor control was 17% with a crude survival of 17%. No intraoperative complications were noted. The delayed morbidity included cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak with bone exposure (1), chronic subdural hematoma (1), septicemia (1), otitis media (1), and severe xerostomia (1). We cannot comment on long-term morbidity due to the relatively short follow-up period of 21 months.

CONCLUSIONS

It is feasible to deliver IOHDR, with acceptable toxicity, to skull base tumors at sites inaccessible to IOEBRT. The use of IOHDR as a pre-radiotherapy boost produced excellent local control and survival in the selected group of patients who had no previous radiation therapy. The use of exclusive IOHDR in the previously irradiated group resulted in poor outcome, possibly due to the limitations on re-irradiation doses and/or volumes determined by normal tissue tolerance or because these patients have inherently radioresistant tumors. Higher IOHDR doses, additional EBRT, and/or chemotherapy should be considered for this group. The use of IOHDR as a pre-EBRT boost to maximize local control has a promising future in the treatment of carefully selected patients with advanced skull base tumor.