Camp B W, Gitterman B, Headley R, Ball V
Department of Pediatrics, University of Colorado School of Medicine, Denver, USA.
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1997 Jan;151(1):78-83. doi: 10.1001/archpedi.1997.02170380082013.
To assess the effectiveness of pediatric residency training as preparation for primary care and make recommendations for improving residency training.
Two surveys were sent to graduate of the pediatric residency at the University of Colorado from 1984 to 1991. The first survey requested information about practice patterns and ratings of preparedness in 45 areas important for primary care. The second survey requested ratings of importance for increasing training time in 25 areas judged as inadequate in the first survey.
Of 147 surveys mailed, 103 graduates responded and rated themselves as less than adequately trained in 25 of 45 areas selected for relevance to primary care. Graduates of the primary care track rated themselves as significantly better trained than graduates of nonprimary care tracks in 10 of 45 areas; nonprimary care graduates had higher ratings in 2 of 45 areas. The second survey (completed by 70 of the 103 initial responders) indicated that the top 5 areas needing increased time in residency training were, in descending order, orthopedics, developmental and behavioral problems, learning disability, attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, and school difficulty. Graduates of the primary care track rated themselves as adequately trained in developmental and behavioral problems and attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, but they and nonprimary care graduates felt inadequately prepared in the other 3 areas.
Implications of these results change with different content areas, suggesting the need to improve training for all residents in some areas and extending to all residents some of the curriculum already implemented in the primary care track.
评估儿科住院医师培训作为初级保健准备工作的有效性,并为改进住院医师培训提出建议。
向科罗拉多大学1984年至1991年儿科住院医师项目的毕业生发送了两份调查问卷。第一份调查问卷要求提供有关45个对初级保健重要领域的实践模式和准备程度评级的信息。第二份调查问卷要求对在第一份调查问卷中被判定为不足的25个领域增加培训时间的重要性进行评级。
在寄出的147份调查问卷中,103名毕业生回复,他们认为自己在所选择的与初级保健相关的45个领域中的25个领域培训不足。初级保健方向的毕业生在45个领域中的10个领域给自己的训练评价明显高于非初级保健方向的毕业生;非初级保健方向的毕业生在45个领域中的2个领域评价更高。第二份调查问卷(由103名最初回复者中的70人完成)表明,住院医师培训中最需要增加时间的前5个领域,按降序排列为骨科、发育和行为问题、学习障碍、注意力缺陷多动障碍和学校适应困难。初级保健方向的毕业生认为自己在发育和行为问题以及注意力缺陷多动障碍方面得到了充分培训,但他们和非初级保健方向的毕业生在其他3个领域感到准备不足。
这些结果的影响因不同内容领域而异,这表明需要在某些领域改进对所有住院医师的培训,并将初级保健方向已经实施的部分课程扩展到所有住院医师。