Fredrikson M, Annas P, Wik G
Department of Clinical Neuroscience, Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden.
Behav Res Ther. 1997 Jan;35(1):23-8. doi: 10.1016/s0005-7967(96)00076-9.
Parental history and experiential factors in the development of snake and spider phobia were studied. Phobic women (DSM-IV, n = 158) reported on family history of animal phobia and whether direct (being frightened by the phobic object) or indirect (seeing someone else being frightened by and/or being warned of the phobic object) fear exposure predated phobia development. Fifty-nine mothers (37%) and 11 fathers (7%) had snake or spider phobia, which is higher than the upper 95% confidence interval in the populations (Fredrikson, Annas, Fischer & Wik, Behavior Research and Therapy, 34, 33-39). Lifetime Relative Risk, RR, of animal phobia in probands' mother and fathers as a function of at least one phobic grandparent was 3.3 and 13.7 respectively. Indirect fear exposures were more common in snake (45%) than spider (27%) phobics (RR = 1.4). Indirect fear exposures were more common among probands with a positive parental history, the RRs being 3.6 and 2.1 as a function of maternal and paternal family history. Direct exposures were unrelated to parental history. The familial resemblance and transmission of specific phobia could be experiential in origin mediated by indirect exposures or of hereditary origin mediated by genetic factors. It may represent genetically facilitated learning and exemplify imprinting in humans.
本研究探讨了父母病史及经验因素在蛇类和蜘蛛恐惧症形成过程中的作用。患有恐惧症的女性(依据《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第四版,n = 158)报告了动物恐惧症的家族病史,以及在恐惧症形成之前,她们是否有过直接(被恐惧对象吓到)或间接(看到他人被恐惧对象吓到和/或被警告有该恐惧对象)的恐惧经历。59位母亲(37%)和11位父亲(7%)患有蛇类或蜘蛛恐惧症,这一比例高于总体人群中95%置信区间的上限(弗雷德里克松等人,《行为研究与治疗》,第34卷,第33 - 39页)。先证者的母亲和父亲患动物恐惧症的终生相对风险(RR),作为至少一位患有恐惧症的祖父母的函数,分别为3.3和13.7。间接恐惧经历在蛇类恐惧症患者(45%)中比在蜘蛛恐惧症患者(27%)中更为常见(RR = 1.4)。在有阳性家族病史的先证者中,间接恐惧经历更为常见,作为母亲和父亲家族病史的函数,RR分别为3.6和2.1。直接恐惧经历与家族病史无关。特定恐惧症的家族相似性和遗传可能源于由间接暴露介导的经验因素,或者源于由遗传因素介导的遗传因素。它可能代表了基因促进的学习,并例证了人类的印记现象。