Korogi Y, Takahashi M, Nakagawa T, Mabuchi N, Watabe T, Shiokawa Y, Shiga H, O'Uchi T, Miki H, Horikawa Y, Fujiwara S, Furuse M
Department of Radiology, Kumamoto University, School of Medicine, Japan.
AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 1997 Jan;18(1):135-43.
To investigate whether obtaining axial source images from three-dimensional Fourier transform (3DFT) time-of-flight MR angiography improves the detection of intracranial vascular stenosis and occlusion if added to maximum-intensity projection (MIP) images.
The angiograms of 103 patients who had MR angiography for evaluation of possible intracranial vascular disease were reviewed retrospectively in a quantitative and nonquantitative fashion. Diameters of vessels on MR angiograms were measured quantitatively by two reviewers using a magnifying loupe and compared with the results from conventional angiograms. Degrees of stenoocclusive disease were categorized into five classes; an artery with stenosis of 50% or greater was considered to be diseased. Another five observers also reviewed the MIP images with and without source images in a blinded fashion by means of nonquantitative visual inspection.
In all, 23 stenoocclusive lesions of 50% or greater were available for review. In the quantitative analysis, with MIP images alone, 14 (78%) of 18 moderate and severe stenoses and four (80%) of five occlusions were identified correctly. The addition of the source images increased the sensitivity to 100% for moderate and severe stenoses and to 100% for occluded vessels. In the visual inspection study, however, no statistically significant differences were found between interpretations of MIP images alone and those of MIP images in combination with source images.
In the quantitative study, interpretation of source images rather than MIP images reduced the tendency to overestimate stenosis seen with MR angiography and improved the sensitivity for detecting stenosis of 50% or greater. There was a discrepancy between the quantitative study and visual inspection. Experienced observers had a tendency to underestimate the degree of stenosis.
研究从三维傅里叶变换(3DFT)时间飞跃磁共振血管造影术中获取轴向源图像并添加到最大强度投影(MIP)图像上,是否能提高颅内血管狭窄和闭塞的检测率。
回顾性定量和非定量分析103例因可能患有颅内血管疾病而行磁共振血管造影的患者的血管造影片。两名阅片者使用放大镜对磁共振血管造影上的血管直径进行定量测量,并与传统血管造影的结果进行比较。将狭窄闭塞性疾病分为五级;狭窄50%或更高的动脉被视为患病。另外五名观察者也以盲法通过非定量视觉检查对有和没有源图像的MIP图像进行了评估。
总共有23处狭窄50%或更高的狭窄闭塞性病变可供评估。在定量分析中,仅使用MIP图像时,18处中度和重度狭窄中的14处(78%)以及5处闭塞中的4处(80%)被正确识别。添加源图像后,中度和重度狭窄的敏感性提高到100%,闭塞血管的敏感性提高到100%。然而,在视觉检查研究中,单独对MIP图像的解读与MIP图像结合源图像的解读之间未发现统计学上的显著差异。
在定量研究中,解读源图像而非MIP图像可减少磁共振血管造影中高估狭窄的倾向,并提高检测50%或更高狭窄的敏感性。定量研究和视觉检查之间存在差异。经验丰富的观察者有低估狭窄程度的倾向。