AbuRahma A F, Short Y S, White J F, Boland J P
Robert C Byrd Health Sciences Center, West Virginia University, Charleston Area Medical Center, USA.
Cardiovasc Surg. 1996 Dec;4(6):783-7. doi: 10.1016/s0967-2109(96)00025-7.
Spontaneous axillary-subclavian vein thrombosis in young patients produces long-term disability. Patients with secondary axillary-subclavian vein thrombosis usually require prolonged venous catheterization for chemotherapy or pacemaking. This study aimed to compare the early and late results of lytic versus anticoagulant therapy in the treatment of axillary-subclavian vein thrombosis, both spontaneous and secondary to central venous cannulation. Nine patients underwent conventional treatment (heparin and warfarin) (group 1), and 10 had initial lytic therapy followed by heparin and warfarin (group 2). Three patients had cervical or first rib resection. Thirteen patients had spontaneous thrombosis and six were secondary to central venous catheterization. The mean follow-up was 36 months. Two of nine patients (22%) in group 1 and eight of 10 patients (80%) in group 2 had total venous recanalization and symptom resolution (P = 0.018). In the spontaneous axillary-subclavian vein thrombosis subset, one of six patients (17%) in group 1 and five of seven patients (71%) in group 2 had total venous recanalization and symptom resolution (P = 0.078). The average difference in cost per patient between groups 1 and 2 was $19,039. In conclusion, lytic therapy appears superior to anticoagulation in the treatment of axillary-subclavian vein thrombosis. However, such treatment is more expensive and its benefits should be carefully weighed against the cost in each case.
年轻患者的自发性腋-锁骨下静脉血栓形成会导致长期残疾。继发性腋-锁骨下静脉血栓形成的患者通常需要长时间进行静脉置管以进行化疗或安装起搏器。本研究旨在比较溶栓治疗与抗凝治疗在治疗自发性及中心静脉置管继发的腋-锁骨下静脉血栓形成的早期和晚期结果。9例患者接受了传统治疗(肝素和华法林)(第1组),10例患者首先接受溶栓治疗,随后接受肝素和华法林治疗(第2组)。3例患者进行了颈椎或第一肋切除术。13例患者为自发性血栓形成,6例继发于中心静脉置管。平均随访时间为36个月。第1组9例患者中有2例(22%)、第2组10例患者中有8例(80%)实现了静脉完全再通且症状缓解(P = 0.018)。在自发性腋-锁骨下静脉血栓形成亚组中,第1组6例患者中有1例(17%)、第2组7例患者中有5例(71%)实现了静脉完全再通且症状缓解(P = 0.078)。第1组和第2组患者的人均费用平均相差19,039美元。总之,在治疗腋-锁骨下静脉血栓形成方面,溶栓治疗似乎优于抗凝治疗。然而,这种治疗费用更高,应在每种情况下仔细权衡其益处与成本。