Pereira J, Hanson J, Bruera E
Grey Nuns Community Health Centre, Cross Cancer Institute, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada.
Cancer. 1997 Feb 15;79(4):835-42.
Cognitive disorders are among the most frequent psychiatric complications of advanced cancer. This study reviews the frequency and clinical course of cognitive failure in patients with advanced cancer admitted to a palliative care unit.
In this retrospective study, all 348 patients admitted to the Edmonton General Palliative Care Unit over a period of 26 months were reviewed. The Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) was used as a screening tool to assess cognitive functioning and was performed on all patients at the time of admission and once to twice weekly thereafter. In all cases, when cognitive failure was diagnosed, a standardized management protocol was followed.
Three hundred and twenty-one patients (92.2%) were evaluable. A total of 1441 MMSEs were performed. Each patient underwent an average of 4.7 +/- 4.26 MMSEs and every patient underwent an MMSE every 4.9 (+/- 3.3) days (median, 3.6 days). The mean age (standard deviation [SD]) of the study group was 64.2 (+/- 12) and the mean +/- SD (median) length of stay was 27 +/- 22 (20.5) days. Two hundred and thirty-one patients (71%) died on the unit. One hundred and forty-two patients (44%) had abnormal MMSE scores (MMSE < 0.8) on admission, whereas 176 patients (55%) had abnormal MMSE scores at the time of death or discharge. Of the 231 patients who died on the unit, 157 (68%) had abnormal MMSE scores prior to death. There was no significant difference in the first MMSE between patients who died and those who were discharged (P = 0.16). Of the 240 patients who underwent 2 or more MMSEs, 99 (41%) had normal initial and final MMSEs, 54 (23%) had normal initial MMSE scores but abnormal final scores, and 62 (26%) had both initial and final abnormal scores. Of the 87 surviving patients with an MMSE score of < 0.8 on admission, 25 (29%) had initial abnormal and final normal scores, indicating an improvement. Twelve of these 25 patients (48%) with abnormal initial scores but normal final scores were discharged versus 52 of 99 patients (53%) with normal initial and final MMSE scores (P > 0.2). Of 124 patients with normal final MMSE scores, 64 (52%) were discharged versus 16 of 116 patients (14%) who had abnormal MMSE final scores (P < 0.0001).
These data suggest that cognitive screening should take place in patients with advanced cancer because cognitive failure is highly prevalent in this population, is reversible in a significant proportion of patients, and the presence of sustained cognitive impairment is a poor prognosticator for discharge. However, these results need to be confirmed in prospective studies.
认知障碍是晚期癌症最常见的精神科并发症之一。本研究回顾了入住姑息治疗病房的晚期癌症患者认知功能衰退的发生率及临床病程。
在这项回顾性研究中,对26个月期间入住埃德蒙顿综合姑息治疗病房的348例患者进行了评估。简易精神状态检查表(MMSE)用作评估认知功能的筛查工具,于所有患者入院时进行,并在其后每周进行一至两次。所有病例一旦确诊为认知功能衰退,均遵循标准化管理方案。
321例患者(92.2%)可纳入评估。共进行了1441次MMSE检查。每位患者平均接受4.7±4.26次MMSE检查,每位患者每4.9(±3.3)天接受一次MMSE检查(中位数为3.6天)。研究组的平均年龄(标准差[SD])为64.2(±12),平均住院时间±SD(中位数)为27±22(20.5)天。231例患者(71%)在病房死亡。142例患者(44%)入院时MMSE评分异常(MMSE<0.8),而176例患者(55%)在死亡或出院时MMSE评分异常。在病房死亡的231例患者中,157例(68%)在死亡前MMSE评分异常。死亡患者与出院患者的首次MMSE评分无显著差异(P = 0.16)。在接受2次或更多次MMSE检查的240例患者中,99例(41%)初次和末次MMSE评分正常,54例(23%)初次MMSE评分正常但末次评分异常,62例(26%)初次和末次评分均异常。入院时MMSE评分<0.8的87例存活患者中,25例(29%)初次评分异常但末次评分正常,表明有所改善。这25例初次评分异常但末次评分正常的患者中有12例(48%)出院,而初次和末次MMSE评分均正常的99例患者中有52例(53%)出院(P>0.2)。在末次MMSE评分正常的124例患者中,64例(52%)出院,而末次MMSE评分异常的116例患者中有16例(14%)出院(P<0.0001)。
这些数据表明,晚期癌症患者应进行认知筛查,因为该人群中认知功能衰退非常普遍,相当一部分患者的认知功能衰退是可逆的,且持续存在认知障碍是出院预后不良的指标。然而,这些结果需要在前瞻性研究中得到证实。