Carbonne B, Goffinet F, Cabrol D
Maternité Port-Royal-Baudelocque, Paris.
J Gynecol Obstet Biol Reprod (Paris). 1996;25(8):783-91.
To compare immediate labor induction by vaginal prostaglandins to immediate labor induction by oxytocin or to expectant management in case of prelabor rupture of the membranes at term.
A meta-analysis of all randomized trials indexed in Medline or in the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews comparing labor induction by vaginal prostaglandins to labor induction by oxytocin or to expectant management. The statistical analysis was performed according to Peto and Yussuf's modified Mantel Haenszel method. The results were expressed as odds-ratios.
Ten published studies meeting the above criteria were found. These trials included 1004 patients. When comparing labor induction by prostaglandins to expectant management, we observed a reduction of the admission-to-delivery interval, a decreased maternal and neonatal infection rate, without difference in the cesarean section rate. When comparing labor induction by vaginal prostaglandins to labor induction by oxytocin, a decreased cesarean section rate was observed without difference in maternal or neonatal infection rates.
Immediate labor induction by vaginal prostaglandins provides better maternal and neonatal outcomes than labor induction by oxytocin or expectant management in case of prelabor rupture of the membranes at term.
比较足月胎膜早破时阴道使用前列腺素引产与缩宫素引产或期待治疗的效果。
对Medline或Cochrane系统评价数据库中索引的所有随机试验进行荟萃分析,比较阴道使用前列腺素引产与缩宫素引产或期待治疗的效果。采用Peto和Yussuf改良的Mantel Haenszel方法进行统计分析。结果以比值比表示。
共找到10项符合上述标准的已发表研究。这些试验纳入了1004例患者。将前列腺素引产与期待治疗进行比较时,我们观察到入院至分娩间隔缩短,母婴感染率降低,剖宫产率无差异。将阴道使用前列腺素引产与缩宫素引产进行比较时,剖宫产率降低,母婴感染率无差异。
足月胎膜早破时,阴道使用前列腺素引产比缩宫素引产或期待治疗能为母婴带来更好的结局。