Escobar-Gutierrez A, Amezcua-Chavarria M E, Pasten-Sanchez S, Ramirez-Casanova E, Cazares J V, Granados G, Loo-Mendez E, Cicero R
Laboratorio de Investigaciones Inmunologicas, Instituto Nacional de Diagnostico y Referencia Epidemiologicos (INDRE), Carpio, Mexico, DF, Mexico.
Int J Lepr Other Mycobact Dis. 1996 Dec;64(4):417-27.
In search for reliable, nonexpensive procedures for tuberculosis diagnosis suitable for seroepidemiological studies in leprosy-endemic areas, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs) with whole intact bacilli, whole lipid-free bacilli and protein-enriched soluble extracts from the H37Rv Mycobacterium tuberculosis strain were evaluated. Sera tested came from 47 active, pulmonary tuberculosis adult cases, 60 household contacts of active tuberculosis cases, 20 lepromatous leprosy adult patients, and 67 healthy adult controls obtained from low and high leprosy and tuberculosis endemicity areas. There was no influence of such endemicity levels in the number of positive results in control sera. Antibody levels obtained with each of the antigens in ELISAs were significantly different in tuberculosis patients and the control groups. Ten percent of tuberculosis contacts were positive with some of the antigens and three of them showed suggestive chest radiographs. The best combination for a high number of positive results with tuberculosis sera and low positive results with leprosy sera was the BCG soluble extract (91% and 15%, respectively). This preparation also yielded excellent sensitivity and specificity values for tuberculosis (91.5% and 92.5%, respectively). These data suggest that BCG soluble extract ELISAs could provide helpful information to estimate tuberculosis prevalence only in leprosy-free areas, under a situation of unavailability of purified antigens. In pulmonary cases, sputum microscopic examination and culture have higher sensibility than serodiagnosis; therefore, the utilization of BCG soluble extract ELISAs as a diagnostic aid in individual patients with suspected active tuberculosis only can be useful in extrapulmonary cases.
为寻找适用于麻风病流行地区血清流行病学研究的可靠且廉价的结核病诊断方法,对采用结核分枝杆菌H37Rv株的完整活菌、全脱脂菌及富含蛋白质的可溶性提取物进行的酶联免疫吸附测定(ELISA)进行了评估。检测的血清来自47例活动性肺结核成年患者、60例活动性肺结核病例的家庭接触者、20例瘤型麻风成年患者以及从麻风病和结核病高、低流行地区选取的67名健康成年对照者。这种流行程度对对照血清中的阳性结果数量没有影响。ELISA中每种抗原所获得的抗体水平在结核病患者和对照组之间存在显著差异。10%的结核病接触者对某些抗原呈阳性,其中三人胸部X线片有提示性表现。在结核病血清中获得大量阳性结果且在麻风病血清中获得少量阳性结果的最佳组合是卡介苗可溶性提取物(分别为91%和15%)。该制剂对结核病也产生了优异的敏感性和特异性值(分别为91.5%和92.5%)。这些数据表明,在无法获得纯化抗原的情况下,卡介苗可溶性提取物ELISA仅能在无麻风病地区为估计结核病患病率提供有用信息。在肺结核病例中,痰涂片显微镜检查和培养比血清诊断具有更高的敏感性;因此,卡介苗可溶性提取物ELISA作为疑似活动性结核病个体患者的诊断辅助手段仅在肺外病例中可能有用。