Kempe A, Wise P H, Wampler N S, Cole F S, Wallace H, Dickinson C, Rinehart H, Lezotte D C, Beaty B
Department of Pediatrics, University of Colorado Health Sciences Center, Denver, USA.
Pediatrics. 1997 Mar;99(3):338-44. doi: 10.1542/peds.99.3.338.
To obtain population-based, clinical information regarding potentially modifiable factors contributing to death during the postneonatal period (28 to 364 days), we examined all postneonatal infant deaths in four areas of the United States to determine: (1) the cause of death from clinical and autopsy data rather than vital statistics, (2) whether death occurred during initial hospitalization or after discharge, and (3) the portion of postneonatal mortality attributable to infants who left the hospital with identified high-risk medical conditions.
Retrospective medical record review of all postneonatal infant deaths with birth weights greater than 500 g (total N = 386) born to mothers residing in: (1) the city of Boston (1984 and 1985, N = 55), (2) the city of St Louis and contiguous areas (1985 and 1986, N = 123), (3) San Diego County (1985, N = 112), and (4) the state of Maine (1984 and 1985, N = 96). Deaths were identified using linked birth and death vital statistics, and medical record audits of infants' and mothers' charts were performed. Causes of death were obtained from medical record review in conjunction with autopsy if performed (72%, N = 278), medical record alone (17%, N = 67), or vital statistics if no other source was available (11%, N = 41). The medical conditions at the time of discharge for each infant were reviewed and, if judged to confer an increased risk of morbidity or mortality, were classified as high risk.
The causes of death were sudden infant death syndrome (47%, N = 181), congenital conditions (20%, N = 77), prematurity-related conditions (11%, N = 43), infections (9%, N = 34), external causes (including injuries, drownings, ingestions, and burns) (7%, N = 25), and other (6%, N = 23). In 24% of congenital and 25% to 44% of prematurity-related deaths, infection was the acute or associated cause of death. Infants born to black mothers were more likely than those born to white mothers to die during the postneonatal period of all major causes of death (7.3 per 1000 vs 3.0 per 1000). Overall, 18% (N = 68) of deaths occurred to infants who never left the hospital; 79% (N = 305) of the infants were discharged before death; and discharge status was unknown in 3% (N = 13). Eighty-one percent of all infants with prematurity-related postneonatal deaths were never discharged, and of the total infants who were initially discharged, only 1% (N = 4) subsequently died of prematurity-related causes. Of all postneonatal deaths, only 16% (N = 62) left the hospital with identified high-risk medical conditions.
These findings suggest that the etiology of postneonatal mortality is heterogeneous, with significant complexity in attributing specific causes of death and making designations of "preventability." The vast majority of infants who died of prematurity-related postneonatal causes never left the hospital, and only a small percentage of all infants that left the hospital before death were identified as being at high medical risk. Therefore, strategies for further decreasing postneonatal mortality must link high-risk follow-up programs to more comprehensive strategies that address risk throughout pregnancy and early childhood.
为获取基于人群的、有关导致出生后新生儿期(28至364天)死亡的潜在可改变因素的临床信息,我们调查了美国四个地区所有出生后新生儿期婴儿死亡情况,以确定:(1)根据临床和尸检数据而非生命统计数据得出的死亡原因;(2)死亡发生在初次住院期间还是出院后;(3)出生后新生儿期死亡中因患有已确诊高危疾病出院的婴儿所占比例。
对所有出生体重超过500克的出生后新生儿期婴儿死亡病例进行回顾性病历审查(总数N = 386),这些婴儿的母亲居住在:(1)波士顿市(1984年和1985年,N = 55);(2)圣路易斯市及周边地区(1985年和1986年,N = 123);(3)圣地亚哥县(1985年,N = 112);(4)缅因州(1984年和1985年,N = 96)。通过关联出生和死亡生命统计数据来确定死亡病例,并对婴儿及母亲的病历进行审查。死亡原因通过病历审查结合尸检结果(若进行尸检)(72%,N = 278)、仅通过病历审查(17%,N = 67)或在无其他信息来源时依据生命统计数据(11%,N = 41)来获取。对每个婴儿出院时的病情进行审查,若判定其发病或死亡风险增加,则归类为高危。
死亡原因包括婴儿猝死综合征(47%,N = 181)、先天性疾病(20%,N = 77)、早产相关疾病(11%,N = 43)、感染(9%,N = 34)、外部原因(包括受伤、溺水、摄入异物和烧伤)(7%,N = 25)以及其他原因(6%,N = 23)。在24%的先天性疾病死亡病例和25%至44%的早产相关疾病死亡病例中,感染是急性或相关死亡原因。黑人母亲所生婴儿在出生后新生儿期因所有主要死亡原因死亡的可能性高于白人母亲所生婴儿(每1000例中有7.3例死亡,而白人母亲所生婴儿为每1000例中有3.0例死亡)。总体而言,18%(N = 68)的死亡病例发生在从未出院的婴儿身上;79%(N = 305)的婴儿在死亡前已出院;3%(N = 13)的出院状态未知。所有早产相关出生后新生儿期死亡的婴儿中,81%从未出院,而在最初出院的婴儿中,只有1%(N = 4)随后死于早产相关原因。在所有出生后新生儿期死亡病例中,只有16%(N = 62)出院时患有已确诊高危疾病。
这些发现表明,出生后新生儿期死亡的病因具有异质性,在确定具体死亡原因和判定“可预防性”方面存在显著复杂性。绝大多数死于早产相关出生后新生儿期病因的婴儿从未出院,在所有死亡前已出院的婴儿中,只有一小部分被确定为高危。因此,进一步降低出生后新生儿期死亡率的策略必须将高危随访项目与更全面的策略相结合,这些策略应涵盖整个孕期和幼儿期的风险问题。