Jolly B T, Massarin E, Pigman E C
Department of Emergency Medicine, George Washington University Medical Center, Washington DC 20037, USA.
Acad Emerg Med. 1997 Feb;4(2):129-32. doi: 10.1111/j.1553-2712.1997.tb03719.x.
To assess the feasibility of emergency physicians' (EPs') performing color-flow Doppler ultrasonographic vascular studies in the ED to diagnose deep venous thrombosis (DVT), after a modest training program.
A retrospective observational review was performed of the performance of color-flow Doppler ultrasonographic vascular studies by EPs. Prior to the study period, venous Doppler studies were not available at off-hours. Two attending EPs were trained by the hospital's vascular laboratory by observing studies and then performing 25-30 studies successfully. They were then available to examine all patients presenting to the ED at off-hours who were suspected of having DVT. Patients were admitted or released from the ED based on the examination results. All patients were to have formal vascular laboratory studies the next day. The study was performed at a university hospital ED and evaluated all patients who underwent off-hour examinations from January 1993 to February 1994. The examiners were aware of the clinical scenario.
Of 23 eligible patients, 15 completed the protocol with a follow-up next-day study. Based on the follow-up study, the ED examination was 100% sensitive (7 true positives) and 75% specific (6 true negatives). The 2 false-positive studies were for patients with old DVT. The 8 patients without follow-up studies were not included in the analysis, although 4 of these patients had negative studies and unremarkable clinical outcomes.
These preliminary findings suggest that Doppler ultrasonographic studies of the lower extremity veins by EPs can be used to make admission decisions when formal studies are not available. Confirmatory studies should be performed. EPs may overread acute thrombosis in the setting of old venous disease. Issues of cost and logistics remain to be resolved.
评估经过适度培训后,急诊医生(EPs)在急诊科进行彩色多普勒超声血管检查以诊断深静脉血栓形成(DVT)的可行性。
对急诊医生进行彩色多普勒超声血管检查的表现进行回顾性观察性研究。在研究期间之前,非工作时间无法进行静脉多普勒检查。两名主治急诊医生由医院血管实验室进行培训,先观察检查过程,然后成功完成25 - 30例检查。随后他们可在非工作时间对所有到急诊科就诊且怀疑患有DVT的患者进行检查。患者根据检查结果收住入院或出院。所有患者次日均需进行正式的血管实验室检查。该研究在一家大学医院急诊科进行,评估了1993年1月至1994年2月期间所有在非工作时间接受检查的患者。检查者知晓临床情况。
在23例符合条件的患者中,15例完成了方案并进行了次日的随访研究。根据随访研究,急诊检查的敏感性为100%(7例假阳性),特异性为75%(6例假阴性)。2例假阳性检查是针对患有陈旧性DVT的患者。8例未进行随访研究的患者未纳入分析,尽管其中4例患者检查结果为阴性且临床结局无异常。
这些初步研究结果表明,当无法进行正式检查时,急诊医生对下肢静脉进行多普勒超声检查可用于做出入院决策。应进行验证性研究。急诊医生在存在陈旧性静脉疾病的情况下可能会高估急性血栓形成。成本和后勤问题仍有待解决。