Phillips K A, Morrison K R, Sonnad S S, Bleecker T
Center for AIDS Prevention Studies, Department of General Internal Medicine, University of California, San Francisco, USA.
J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr Hum Retrovirol. 1997 Feb 1;14(2):174-8. doi: 10.1097/00042560-199702010-00012.
This study describes primary care providers' beliefs and self-reported practices regarding HIV counseling and testing of pregnant women and women of childbearing age. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommends that providers counsel and encourage all pregnant women and women of childbearing age to be voluntarily tested, and California requires providers to offer voluntary testing to all pregnant women. We randomly sampled 180 primary care providers in 1995 from the nine-county San Francisco Bay area using a self-administered, mailed survey (response rate = 73%, N = 121). Eighty-six percent of primary care providers (obstetricians/gynecologists, internists, family practitioners, or general practitioners) support voluntary testing, 61% support routine testing without explicit consent, and 55% support mandatory testing. Although 90% of providers are very likely to encourage pregnant women with risk factors to be tested, only 34% are very likely to encourage pregnant women without risk factors to be tested and only 9% are very likely to encourage women of childbearing age without risk factors to be tested. Few providers state that they support policies targeting testing to women with risk factors, yet in practice, providers are much more likely to encourage testing for women with risk factors than those without risk factors. We conclude that providers may be missing opportunities to encourage women to be tested, and women may not be receiving adequate information to make an informed testing decision. Future research is needed to determine the viability of voluntary testing and how to remove barriers to its implementation.
本研究描述了初级保健提供者对于孕妇及育龄妇女进行HIV咨询与检测的信念及自我报告的做法。疾病控制与预防中心(CDC)建议医疗服务提供者为所有孕妇及育龄妇女提供咨询并鼓励她们自愿接受检测,加利福尼亚州要求医疗服务提供者为所有孕妇提供自愿检测服务。1995年,我们通过自行填写并邮寄的调查问卷,从旧金山湾区的9个县随机抽取了180名初级保健提供者(回复率 = 73%,N = 121)。86%的初级保健提供者(妇产科医生、内科医生、家庭医生或全科医生)支持自愿检测,61%支持未经明确同意的常规检测,55%支持强制检测。虽然90%的医疗服务提供者很可能会鼓励有危险因素的孕妇接受检测,但只有34%很可能会鼓励无危险因素的孕妇接受检测,只有9%很可能会鼓励无危险因素的育龄妇女接受检测。很少有医疗服务提供者表示他们支持针对有危险因素的女性进行检测的政策,但实际上,医疗服务提供者鼓励有危险因素的女性接受检测的可能性远高于无危险因素的女性。我们得出结论,医疗服务提供者可能错失了鼓励女性接受检测的机会,而女性可能没有获得足够的信息来做出明智的检测决定。未来需要开展研究以确定自愿检测的可行性以及如何消除其实施过程中的障碍。