Fletcher-Flinn C, Elmes H, Strugnell D
Department of Psychology, Faculty of Science, University of Auckland, New Zealand.
Dev Med Child Neurol. 1997 Mar;39(3):158-66. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-8749.1997.tb07404.x.
Much research has shown that children with congenital developmental coordination disorder (CDCD) have marked impairments in the perception of visual-spatial information, a deficit which has been assumed to be causally related to difficulties that many CDCD children experience when learning to read and spell. However, current research in reading disability suggests that poor reading is mainly related to difficulties with the processing of phonological information or with metaphonological ability, not to visual-perceptual deficits. This study aimed to explore the relationship between reading achievement and the visual-perceptual, phonological and general cognitive ability of CDCD children. Twenty-eight children with a mean age of 8.3 years were tested on motor coordination, language, general ability, visual discrimination, visual-motor integration, phoneme awareness, phoneme discrimination, reading and spelling. Results showed that phoneme awareness was the most strongly related to reading and spelling performance, and that visual discrimination showed no relationship to reading ability, although it was related to spelling performance, phonological awareness, and motor coordination. These results suggest that CDCD children who have difficulty with the acquisition of literacy may suffer from visual-perceptual problems and metaphonological deficits, but these problems are differentially related to reading and spelling.
大量研究表明,患有先天性发育协调障碍(CDCD)的儿童在视觉空间信息感知方面存在明显缺陷,人们认为这一缺陷与许多CDCD儿童在学习阅读和拼写时遇到的困难存在因果关系。然而,目前关于阅读障碍的研究表明,阅读能力差主要与语音信息处理困难或元语音能力有关,而非视觉感知缺陷。本研究旨在探讨CDCD儿童的阅读成绩与视觉感知、语音和一般认知能力之间的关系。对28名平均年龄为8.3岁的儿童进行了运动协调、语言、一般能力、视觉辨别、视动整合、音素意识、音素辨别、阅读和拼写测试。结果表明,音素意识与阅读和拼写表现的相关性最强,视觉辨别与阅读能力无关,尽管它与拼写表现、语音意识和运动协调有关。这些结果表明,在识字方面有困难的CDCD儿童可能存在视觉感知问题和元语音缺陷,但这些问题与阅读和拼写的关系各不相同。