Hauffa B P, Winter A, Stolecke H
Dept. of Pediatric Endocrinology, University Children's Hospital, University of Essen, F. R. Germany.
Klin Padiatr. 1997 Mar-Apr;209(2):71-7. doi: 10.1055/s-2008-1043931.
In clinical practice, height velocity and rate of bone maturation during each follow-up interval are among the parameters used to modify glucocorticoid treatment in children with 21-hydroxylase deficiency. There is controversy on the relative importance of treatment and disease variables for short-term growth and final height.
Short- and long-term growth data of 87 patients (n = 35 salt-wasting form; n = 52 simple virilizing form) were analysed retrospectively by stepwise multiple regression.
Height SDS for chronological age (HtSDSCA) was elevated prior to treatment in boys (m = 3.22, p < 0.0001) and decreased when compared to HtSDSCA > or = 4 years after the start of treatment in both boys (m = -0.64, p < 0.0001) and girls (m = -1.24, p < 0.0023). When the simultaneous effects of hydrocortisone dose, salt-wasting status, degree of hormonal control, and patient sex on short-term growth between follow-up visits were analysed, only a minor effect of hydrocortisone dose (partial coefficient of determination [Pr2] = 0.04, p < 0.011) and salt-wasting status (Pr2 = 0.03, p < 0.024) in the prepubertal group, and a small effect of the treatment quality rating in the pubertal group (Pr2 = 0.07, p < 0.0042) on height velocity SDS for chronological age (HVSDSCA) were noted. Height velocity SDS for bone age (HVSDSBA) was influenced to a similar degree by treatment quality (Pr2 = 0.098, p < 0.0017) in the prepubertal, and by hydrocortisone dose (Pr2 = 0.063, p < 0.021) in the pubertal group. Mean daily hydrocortisone doses used in normally growing patients ranged between 17.9 and 21.8 mg/m2/d if analysed separately for sex and salt-wasting status. 34 patients had reached final height which with the exception of one boy was below the population mean and ranged from 82.3% to 100.1% of target height in the total group. 41.2% of the patients had adult short stature (HtSDS < -2). Treatment with synthetic glucocorticoids for more than 1 year started before the age of 1.5 years was associated with the most severely compromised final height SDS (m = -3.73, p < 0.029).
The proportion of the short-term height velocity SDS that can be explained by the tested treatment and disease variables is low (< or = 9.8%). Conclusions drawn from observed changes in height velocity during single short follow-up intervals on treatment modalities must therefore be viewed with caution. In the long run, however, use of daily hydrocortisone doses > 25 mg/m2/day and of synthetic glucocorticoids started early in the course of the disease does not only lead to a transient deceleration of height velocity in growing children with 21-hydroxylase deficiency, but carries a definite risk for decreased final height.
在临床实践中,每次随访间隔期间的身高增长速度和骨成熟速率是用于调整21-羟化酶缺乏症患儿糖皮质激素治疗的参数。关于治疗和疾病变量对短期生长和最终身高的相对重要性存在争议。
对87例患者(35例失盐型;52例单纯男性化型)的短期和长期生长数据进行回顾性逐步多元回归分析。
治疗前男孩的按年龄计算的身高标准差评分(HtSDSCA)升高(均值=3.22,p<0.0001),治疗开始≥4年后与治疗前相比,男孩(均值=-0.64,p<0.0001)和女孩(均值=-1.24,p<0.0023)的HtSDSCA均降低。分析随访期间氢化可的松剂量、失盐状态、激素控制程度和患者性别对短期生长的联合影响时,仅青春期前组氢化可的松剂量(决定系数偏回归系数[Pr2]=0.04,p<0.011)和失盐状态(Pr2=0.03,p<0.024),以及青春期组治疗质量评分(Pr2=0.07,p<0.0042)对按年龄计算的身高增长速度标准差评分(HVSDSCA)有较小影响。青春期前组骨龄身高增长速度标准差评分(HVSDSBA)受治疗质量影响程度相似(Pr2=0.098,p<0.0017),青春期组受氢化可的松剂量影响(Pr2=0.063,p<0.021)。若按性别和失盐状态分别分析,正常生长患者使用的平均每日氢化可的松剂量在17.9至21.8mg/m²/天之间。34例患者已达到最终身高,除1名男孩外,均低于总体均值,在整个组中占目标身高的82.3%至100.1%。41.2%的患者成年后身材矮小(HtSDS<-2)。1.5岁前开始使用合成糖皮质激素治疗超过1年与最终身高标准差评分受损最严重相关(均值=-3.73,p<0.029)。
经测试的治疗和疾病变量所能解释的短期身高增长速度标准差的比例较低(≤9.8%)。因此,基于单次短期随访期间观察到的身高增长速度变化得出的关于治疗方式的结论必须谨慎看待。然而,从长远来看,每日使用氢化可的松剂量>25mg/m²/天以及在疾病早期开始使用合成糖皮质激素,不仅会导致21-羟化酶缺乏症生长中儿童的身高增长速度暂时减慢,而且确实存在最终身高降低的风险。