Bougerol T, Farisse J
Psychiatre des Hôpitaux, Hôpital Sainte-Marguerite, Marseille.
Encephale. 1996 Dec;22 Spec No 5:46-53.
The concept of Panic Disorders has itself been developed on the strength of therapeutic effects of drug treatments and it is therefore not surprising that psychotropic medications are currently the main therapeutic tool for this condition. Their use may be indicated in two differing circumstances, as treatment for Panic Attack itself or as a long-term treatment for what is properly called Panic Disorder. The latter scenario is that which has been most actively studied and represents the more original side of the question. Treatment of acute Panic Attack involves administration of sedative anxiolytics, principally benzodiazepines (BZD). Long-term treatment aiming to prevent repeated attacks is the core strategy for treatment for Panic Disorder. For the past fifteen years, a large number of research projects have shown the elective anti-panic efficacy of a number of drugs, principally antidepressants and anxiolytics. The response profile to anti-depressant treatment is characterized by a lag time which is sometimes longer than that observed when they are used solely as antidepressants; frequently they are also less well tolerated which necessitates a very gradual step-up in dosage. The "classic" MAOI (non-selective and irreversible) have a proven anti-panic effect. Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) anti-depressants are currently drugs of choice in the treatment of Panic Disorder. Although the anti-panic effect appears to be common to all the various SSRI drugs available, and directly attributable to their mechanism of action, not all of them however have undergone controlled studies. In France, paroxetine is the first anti-depressant in this group to obtain a marketing authorization for this particular indication. The advantages of the SSRI drugs are principally related to their limited adverse effects and lack of toxicity, thereby making them particularly straightforward to use. Benzodiazepines (BZD) are the second group of psychotropic medications which have been shown to be effective in the treatment of Panic Disorder. The major disadvantage of the BZD for this indication is chiefly related to the major risk of promoting a dependency state with the corresponding appearance of a withdrawal syndrome when treatment is stopped. This risk constitutes a major stumbling block to the use of BZD as a first-line treatment for Panic Disorder. Various other drugs have been evaluated in the treatment of Panic Disorder with varying success. The current anti-panic pharmacopoeia therefore appears to be relatively well stocked. In this context, antidepressants-especially the SSRI drugs-are the first-line treatment of choice for Panic Disorders. In all cases, it appears useful to integrate pharmacological treatment within an overall management plan for the patient with Panic Disorder, especially if it is hoped to maintain therapeutic benefit long-term.
惊恐障碍的概念本身是基于药物治疗的效果发展而来的,因此精神药物目前是治疗这种疾病的主要治疗手段也就不足为奇了。它们的使用可能适用于两种不同的情况,作为惊恐发作本身的治疗方法,或者作为对真正意义上的惊恐障碍的长期治疗。后一种情况是研究最为活跃的,也是问题中更具原创性的方面。急性惊恐发作的治疗包括使用镇静抗焦虑药,主要是苯二氮䓬类药物(BZD)。旨在预防反复发作的长期治疗是惊恐障碍治疗的核心策略。在过去的十五年里,大量的研究项目表明,许多药物具有选择性抗惊恐作用,主要是抗抑郁药和抗焦虑药。抗抑郁治疗的反应特征是有一个延迟期,有时比单独用作抗抑郁药时观察到的延迟期更长;它们的耐受性通常也较差,这就需要非常缓慢地增加剂量。“经典的”单胺氧化酶抑制剂(非选择性和不可逆的)具有已被证实的抗惊恐作用。选择性5-羟色胺再摄取抑制剂(SSRI)类抗抑郁药目前是治疗惊恐障碍的首选药物。尽管所有可用的各种SSRI药物似乎都有抗惊恐作用,并且直接归因于它们的作用机制,但并非所有药物都经过了对照研究。在法国,帕罗西汀是该类中第一个获得这一特定适应症上市许可的抗抑郁药。SSRI药物的优点主要与其副作用有限和无毒性有关,因此使用起来特别简单。苯二氮䓬类药物(BZD)是第二类已被证明对治疗惊恐障碍有效的精神药物。BZD用于这一适应症的主要缺点主要与产生依赖状态的主要风险有关,当治疗停止时会相应出现戒断综合征。这一风险构成了将BZD用作惊恐障碍一线治疗药物的主要障碍。在惊恐障碍的治疗中,对各种其他药物也进行了评估,取得了不同程度的成功。因此,目前的抗惊恐药典似乎储备相对充足。在这种情况下,抗抑郁药——尤其是SSRI药物——是惊恐障碍的一线首选治疗药物。在所有情况下,将药物治疗纳入惊恐障碍患者的整体管理计划似乎是有用的,特别是如果希望长期保持治疗效果的话。