Nijman H L, Merckelbach H L, Allertz W F, a Campo J M
Psychiatric Hospital, Heerlen, The Netherlands.
Psychiatr Serv. 1997 May;48(5):694-8. doi: 10.1176/ps.48.5.694.
This study examined whether staff members' use of interventions for preventing patients' aggression reduced the number of incidents of aggression on a closed acute admissions ward of a psychiatric hospital in the Netherlands.
The number and severity of incidents of aggression on three closed wards were measured using the Dutch version of the Staff Observation Aggression Scale (SOAS). Measurements were made for three months before and after staff implemented interventions for preventing aggression on one of the wards. Interventions included a protocol for talking to patients who exhibited aggressive behavior, discussing treatment goals with the patient shortly after admission, explaining why the ward's door was locked and the exit rules, providing a schedule of staff meetings to explain staff members' absence from the ward, and clarifying the procedure for making an appointment with the psychiatrists.
The frequency of aggressive incidents was reduced on all three wards, with no significant difference between the ward where the interventions were implemented and the two control wards. A marginally significant difference in the severity of aggressive incidents was found between experimental and control wards after the introduction of the preventive measures, with incidents in the experimental ward tending to be less severe.
This study failed to find a robust effect of specific intervention measures on aggressive incidents. However, it did find evidence suggesting that standardized reporting by staff of aggressive incidents on closed psychiatric wards may in itself result in straightforward reduction of violent incidents.
本研究探讨了荷兰一家精神病医院封闭急性收治病房的工作人员采用预防患者攻击行为的干预措施后,攻击事件的数量是否有所减少。
使用荷兰版的工作人员观察攻击量表(SOAS)对三个封闭病房的攻击事件数量和严重程度进行测量。在工作人员对其中一个病房实施预防攻击行为的干预措施之前和之后的三个月进行测量。干预措施包括与表现出攻击行为的患者交谈的方案、入院后不久与患者讨论治疗目标、解释病房门为何上锁及出院规则、提供工作人员会议时间表以解释工作人员不在病房的原因,以及阐明预约精神科医生的程序。
所有三个病房的攻击事件频率均有所降低,实施干预措施的病房与两个对照病房之间无显著差异。在采取预防措施后,实验组和对照组病房在攻击事件严重程度上存在微弱的显著差异,实验组病房的事件往往不太严重。
本研究未能发现特定干预措施对攻击事件有显著效果。然而,研究确实发现有证据表明,封闭精神科病房的工作人员对攻击事件进行标准化报告本身可能会直接减少暴力事件。