Matsumura T, Kang J, Nozaki S, Takahashi M P
Department of Neurology Toneyama National Hospital.
Rinsho Shinkeigaku. 1997 Feb;37(2):87-92.
We studied the functional outcome of spinal fusion for the surgical treatment of scoliosis in 8 patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). The mean age of DMD patients at the time of the surgery and the mean follow-up duration was 13.8 (12.3 to 15.4) and 3.9 (1.5 to 6.8) years, respectively. The average spinal angle (Cobb angle) was corrected from 58.8 to 28.6 degrees with the mean corrective rate of 51.3% by the surgical intervention. The correction rate was higher and the corrected Cobb angle remained unchanged during follow-up period in mildly scoliotic patients. Forced vital capacity (FVC) increased post-operatively in 3 patients with moderate scoliosis (Cobb angle: 50 to 80 degrees), indicating that the correction of spinal alignment is effective for the treatment of decreased thoracic volume in DMD. On the other hand, two cases with low % FVC (16.9% and 30.4%, respectively) had poor prognosis in respiratory status. Namely, one died of pneumonia at 17 months after the surgery and the other required mechanical ventilation via nasal mask at 3 years post surgery. Sitting balance improved in all patients, which resulted in more functional use of their upper extremities. During the follow-up period, all patients except one patient who died of pneumonia could maintain sitting balance without support. Moreover these included 2 patients over 20 year old. No complications related to spinal deformities have been found in these patients. Previous study in our hospital showed that 7 of 48 (14.6%) of DMD patients spent all their lives without apparent scoliosis (Cobb angle less than 30 degrees). These suggest that spinal fusion could be recommended for patients with Cobb angle more than 30 degrees and with % FVC more than 35%. Although the impact of spinal fusion upon the life expectancy remains unclear, favorable effect on respiratory function and quality of life can be expected for carefully selected patients with DMD.
我们研究了8例杜氏肌营养不良症(DMD)患者脊柱融合术治疗脊柱侧弯的功能预后。DMD患者手术时的平均年龄和平均随访时间分别为13.8岁(12.3至15.4岁)和3.9年(1.5至6.8年)。通过手术干预,平均脊柱角度(Cobb角)从58.8度矫正至28.6度,平均矫正率为51.3%。轻度脊柱侧弯患者的矫正率更高,且在随访期间矫正后的Cobb角保持不变。3例中度脊柱侧弯(Cobb角:50至80度)患者术后用力肺活量(FVC)增加,表明脊柱排列矫正对治疗DMD患者胸廓容积减小有效。另一方面,2例FVC百分比低的患者(分别为16.9%和30.4%)呼吸状况预后较差。也就是说,1例患者术后17个月死于肺炎,另1例患者术后3年需要通过鼻罩进行机械通气。所有患者的坐位平衡均有所改善,从而使上肢的功能使用更多。在随访期间,除1例死于肺炎的患者外,所有患者均可在无支撑的情况下保持坐位平衡。此外,其中包括2例年龄超过20岁的患者。这些患者未发现与脊柱畸形相关的并发症。我院之前的研究表明,48例DMD患者中有7例(14.6%)一生未出现明显脊柱侧弯(Cobb角小于30度)。这些表明,对于Cobb角大于30度且FVC百分比大于35%的患者可推荐进行脊柱融合术。尽管脊柱融合术对预期寿命的影响尚不清楚,但对于精心挑选的DMD患者,有望对呼吸功能和生活质量产生有利影响。