Chataigner H, Grelet V, Onimus M
Service de Chirurgie des Scolioses et Orthopédie Infantile, Hôpital Saint-Jacques, Besançon.
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot. 1998 May;84(3):224-30.
The authors present a retrospective review of 27 patients presenting a Duchenne muscular dystrophy and who were operated for spinal deformity, with special reference to functional result and postoperative evolution of vital capacity.
Age at surgery averaged 14. Mean scoliotic angulation was 42 degrees. A thoraco-lumbar kyphosis was present in 15 cases (kyphotic index less than 10 degrees). A pelvic obliquity averaging 17 degrees was associated in 19 cases. Mean pre-operative vital capacity was 56 per cent. Preoperative evolution of vital capacity was documented in 18 cases: annual rate of decrease was 4.3 per cent. Heart ejection fraction averaged 63 per cent in 23 cases, and was normal in 4 cases. Instrumentation was extended from D3, D4 or D5 to L5 (5 cases) or S1 (22 cases). Spinal fixation was done in all patients by subliminar wiring with Luque rods (5 cases) or Hartshill rectangle (22 cases). Sacral fixation was done with ilio-sacral screws linked to the rectangle by Cotrel Dubousset rods and dominos (15 cases).
Mean blood loss was 1750 cc. Postoperatively, 25 patients were extubated on the operative day, 1 patient at D + 1, and one patient underwent a tracheostomy after one month. Scoliosis was reduced to 10 degrees after surgery and 13 degrees after 30 months follow-up. Pelvic obliquity was reduced to 4 degrees after surgery and 7 degrees after 30 months. A good spinal balance was present after surgery in 20 patients; at follow-up, a coronal or sagittal imbalance averaging 40 mm was observed in 22 patients. Postoperative evolution of vital capacity was documented in 21 cases. The annual decrease rate was 6.4 per cent. Rate was higher in patients presenting a good preoperative vital capacity (over 70 per cent) and very low in patients presenting a preoperative vital capacity under 40 per cent. 10 patients were deceased at review after a mean 53 months survival, at a mean age of 19. 17 patients were alive with a 50 months follow-up.
Spinal surgery in Duchenne muscular dystrophy has a low morbidity. It allows to keep sitting position to the child and to preserve quality of life. Surgery should be considered as soon as frontal or sagittal collapse of the spine is observed. However surgery does not result in respiratory improvement nor in life duration lengthening.
作者对27例患有杜氏肌营养不良症并接受脊柱畸形手术的患者进行了回顾性研究,特别关注功能结果和术后肺活量的变化。
手术时的平均年龄为14岁。平均脊柱侧弯角度为42度。15例存在胸腰段后凸(后凸指数小于10度)。19例伴有平均17度的骨盆倾斜。术前平均肺活量为56%。18例记录了术前肺活量的变化:年下降率为4.3%。23例患者的心脏射血分数平均为63%,4例正常。内固定范围从D3、D4或D5延伸至L5(5例)或S1(22例)。所有患者均通过使用Luque棒(5例)或Hartshill矩形装置(22例)进行椎板下钢丝固定来完成脊柱固定。15例通过Cotrel Dubousset棒和连接体将髂骶螺钉与矩形装置相连来进行骶骨固定。
平均失血量为1750毫升。术后,25例患者在手术当天拔管,1例在术后第1天拔管,1例在1个月后进行了气管切开术。脊柱侧弯术后降至10度,30个月随访后为13度。骨盆倾斜术后降至4度,30个月后为7度。20例患者术后脊柱平衡良好;随访时,22例患者观察到冠状面或矢状面平均失衡40毫米。21例记录了术后肺活量的变化。年下降率为6.4%。术前肺活量良好(超过70%)的患者下降率较高,术前肺活量低于40%的患者下降率很低。复查时,10例患者在平均存活53个月后死亡,平均年龄为19岁。17例患者存活,随访50个月。
杜氏肌营养不良症的脊柱手术发病率较低。它能使患儿保持坐姿并维持生活质量。一旦观察到脊柱出现额状面或矢状面塌陷,就应考虑手术。然而,手术并不能改善呼吸功能,也不能延长生存期。