Wilcke J T, Kok-Jensen A
Department P of Pulmonary Medicine, Bispebjerg Hospital, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Respir Med. 1997 May;91(5):281-5. doi: 10.1016/s0954-6111(97)90031-7.
The referral centre of tuberculosis in the municipality of Copenhagen, Denmark was the setting for this study, which aimed to assess the diagnostic strategy (chest X-ray and clinical mycobacteriology) in pulmonary tuberculosis. Patient records and chest X-rays were examined for all patients who had sputum or gastric lavage examined for Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) from 1 January 1992 to 30 April 1994. All chest X-rays were re-evaluated by a trained lung specialist, who did not know the results of sputum culture. Evaluation was referred to one of seven X-ray categories, and compared to the results of culture. Culture of sputum or gastric lavage were positive for Mtb in 54 (14%) of 392 patients; in 61% of 59 patients with X-ray changes thought to be due to tuberculosis (TB); in 20% of 51 patients with X-ray changes compatible with TB; in 14% of 35 patients with previous TB and radiographically active TB; in 2% of 103 patients with previous TB, but not radiographically active TB; in 1% of 112 patients with X-ray changes thought to be due to other disease; and none out of 32 patients with normal X-ray. Even in this highly selected material, it is relatively expensive to find the very few cases of active TB in patients with chest X-ray changes not suspected to be due to TB. It is recommended that: (1) examination of sputum for Mtb should always be preceded by X-ray of the chest in a low-prevalence country; (2) routine culture of sputum for Mtb is restricted to patients with X-ray changes typical or compatible with active TB; and (3) exceptions to this general rule should be made on the basis of the individual's clinical history.
丹麦哥本哈根市的结核病转诊中心是本研究的开展地点,该研究旨在评估肺结核的诊断策略(胸部X线检查和临床分枝杆菌学检查)。对1992年1月1日至1994年4月30日期间所有接受痰或洗胃检查以查找结核分枝杆菌(Mtb)的患者的病历和胸部X线片进行了检查。所有胸部X线片均由一名经过培训的肺部专家重新评估,该专家不知道痰培养结果。评估被归入七个X线类别之一,并与培养结果进行比较。392例患者中有54例(14%)痰或洗胃培养出Mtb呈阳性;59例胸部X线改变被认为是由结核病(TB)引起的患者中,61%培养呈阳性;51例胸部X线改变与TB相符的患者中,20%培养呈阳性;35例既往有TB且胸部X线显示活动性TB的患者中,14%培养呈阳性;103例既往有TB但胸部X线无活动性TB表现的患者中,2%培养呈阳性;112例胸部X线改变被认为是由其他疾病引起的患者中,1%培养呈阳性;32例胸部X线正常的患者中无一例培养呈阳性。即使在这种经过高度筛选的病例材料中,在胸部X线改变不怀疑由TB引起的患者中发现极少数活动性TB病例的成本也相对较高。建议:(1)在结核病低流行国家,对痰进行Mtb检查前应始终先进行胸部X线检查;(2)痰Mtb常规培养仅限于胸部X线改变典型或与活动性TB相符的患者;(3)应根据个体的临床病史对这一一般规则做出例外处理。