Ziran B H, Sharkey N A, Smith T S, Wang G, Chapman M W
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, University of California, Davis, Sacramento, USA.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1997 Jun(339):82-91. doi: 10.1097/00003086-199706000-00012.
It was hypothesized that transverse locking screws of intramedullary nails, seated above the lesser trochanter, provide equal strength to that of reconstruction nails, and that screws placed through the medial cortex of the femoral neck do not have adverse biomechanical effects during physiologic loading. Synthetic femurs (n = 10) and paired anatomic specimen femurs (n = 14) were tested intact and with an intramedullary device in place. Intact specimens were loaded nondestructively, then a segmental subtrochanteric defect was created and either a high seated transverse locking nail or a reconstruction nail was inserted and statistically locked. Axial and torsional stiffness were determined followed by axial failure testing. Mechanical parameters evaluated were stiffness, displacement, and energy. The implanted specimens did not show any statistically significant difference between transverse or reconstruction screw constructs with any of the measured parameters (stiffness, displacement, and energy). Failure tests in implanted specimens also did not show any statistically significant difference in yield load, yield displacement, or energy to failure between implant constructs. All anatomic specimens failed, with fractures of the proximal fragment involving medial and lateral cortices. Synthetic specimens did not fracture but showed failure with implant deformation at the level of the skeletal defect. The use of high seated transverse locking nails for complex proximal femoral fractures is a viable option and has comparable in vitro mechanical performance with reconstruction nails. Although not shown to be a problem in the present study, clinical evaluation of screws through the medial femoral neck cortex is required.
研究假设,位于小转子上方的髓内钉横向锁定螺钉与重建钉具有同等强度,且穿过股骨颈内侧皮质的螺钉在生理负荷下不会产生不良生物力学影响。对10根合成股骨和14对解剖标本股骨进行完整测试,并在其内置入髓内装置。对完整标本进行无损加载,然后制造转子下节段性缺损,插入高位横向锁定钉或重建钉并进行统计学锁定。测定轴向和扭转刚度,随后进行轴向破坏试验。评估的力学参数包括刚度、位移和能量。植入标本在横向或重建螺钉结构的任何测量参数(刚度、位移和能量)之间均未显示出任何统计学上的显著差异。植入标本的破坏试验在植入结构之间的屈服载荷、屈服位移或破坏能量方面也未显示出任何统计学上的显著差异。所有解剖标本均发生骨折,近端骨折块的骨折累及内侧和外侧皮质。合成标本未发生骨折,但在骨骼缺损水平处出现植入物变形的破坏情况。对于复杂的股骨近端骨折,使用高位横向锁定钉是一种可行的选择,并且在体外力学性能上与重建钉相当。尽管在本研究中未显示出问题,但仍需要对穿过股骨颈内侧皮质的螺钉进行临床评估。